. Yglesias argues
that yards are nothing but wasted space and sprawl, and that cities
shouldn’t encourage them or set zoning requirements for them. What is
surprising is that even from what should be his most supportive
audience, the readers of Slate Magazine, the overwhelming reaction he
gets from his commentators is disagreement. Readers tell him if he
didn’t want a yard, he shouldn’t have bought a house with a yard; he
should have rented an apartment or bought a condominium instead. But he
should let other people live in the kind of housing they prefer and not
complain about it. A healthy city life is about providing a variety of
choices for people at various stages of their lives, not about fitting
everyone in a one-size-fits-all "smart growth" straight jacket.
#####
The reputation of the March on Washington will survive its
reenactment this coming weekend, but it won’t be enhanced by it. It will
be better to treat the upcoming event as a tribute to what was a unique
inspiring gathering and a turning point in American history a half
century ago than to compare and contrast it to the original.
Gary Imhoff
themail@dcwatch.com
###############
When the Council Reconvenes
Dorothy Brizill,
dorothy@dcwatch.com
The council will end its summer recess in mid-September, and will
hold its first legislative session on September 17. The Large Retailer
Accountability Act (B20-62), also known as the living wage bill, which
was passed by the council at its last legislative session, on July 10,
will serve as the backdrop for a pitched battle between the council and
the mayor when the legislative body reconvenes. Gray, concerned about
the threats from Walmart to abandon its plan to build six stores in the
District and warnings from other retailers, has hinted that he is likely
to veto the bill. Meanwhile, the bill’s supporters, including eight
councilmembers — Bonds, Evans, Grosso, Orange, Barry, Graham, and
McDuffie, and Mendelson — will need the support of at least one more
councilmember in order to overrule a mayoral veto.
The council’s September agenda will also include several issues that
could impact the 2014 elections, e.g., whether to hold the
District’s primary election on April 1 or to reschedule it to June (Phil
Mendelson has an emergency bill he plans to introduce to shift the date)
and whether t postpone the first election of DC’s attorney general from
2014 to 2018 (such an amendment is attached to a bill on the role and
duties of the office of the AG that will have its second reading on
September 17).
On or about September 17, Councilmember Kenyan McDuffie, chair of the
Council’s Government Operations Committee, will introduce a
comprehensive campaign finance reform bill that will consolidate in a
single bill the key provisions contained in the more than twelve
campaign finance reform bills what have been introduce in the council in
the past year. McDuffie will then hold a public hearing on the bill and
try to schedule a vote and secure council approval in the fall (October
or November). In addition to reviewing substantive changes in the
District’s campaign finance laws and regulations, the council will also
have to determine when any of those changes will be implemented. Since
nominating petitions are scheduled to be released to candidates in the
April 2014 primary by the DC Board of Elections on November 8, the
council and the mayor will have to agree on which reform measure can be
implemented during the 2014 election cycle.
The July 25th term agreement regarding the construction of a new DC
United stadium at Buzzard’s Point in southwest has a very tight
timetable. Under the term agreement, the "Transaction Agreements"
between the District and DC United must be finalized by October 1, and
the council must give legal approval to the stadium deal by January 1,
2014. As a result, the fall session of the council could provide the
backdrop for a protracted political battle over a new stadium similar to
the very nasty fight over the construction of the Nationals baseball
stadium.
Other important issues that will be considered by the council when it
reconvenes include: a) council approval of a new CEO to replace Natwar
Gandhi; b) legislation to reform the District’s CBE (local and minority
business) program; c) legislation to underground Pepco’s power lines; d)
competing education legislative proposed by David Catania (seven
separate bills) and Mayor Gray; and e) sanctions to be imposed by the
council on Councilmember Marion Barry for accepting $6800 in gifts from
two city contractors.
###############
My Only Experience in a DC School
Tom Grahame,
tgrahame@mindspring.com
I don’t have kids. As a lifetime public policy person, though, I have
always cared about schooling, especially inner city schooling.
Throughout the 1970’s and 1980’s, I would read every year or so about
some new innovation that this time, this time, would cause inner city
kids to learn more. And they never did; the scores were always dismal.
In the late 1990s, in Washington Monthly (started and edited
by Charles Peters, a Democrat who headed JFK’s Kanawha County, West
Virginia, campaign), there was an article explaining in great detail all
the reasons why public schools could not improve. The longish story was
centered around Chicago’s attempt to fire a truly bad teacher. It went
through the courts for years, with the teacher eventually winning, and
eventually getting several million dollars. There were many issues in
that article, most dealing with how over-lawyering tied the hands of the
best teachers. After that, and based on my previous reading as well, I
decided that I had to support a new type of urban public school, charter
schools. They would have a bit more freedom to do things right, I
thought. It was a gamble, but it had to be better than continually
failing so many kids, giving them little or no chance for the kind of
job that would earn them enough money to move someplace safe, to be able
to contribute.
Fast forward to about 2007. I got a chance to tour the SEED school, a
charter school that is also an in-town boarding school. Local kids slept
at the school’s dormitory five nights a week and went home for the
weekend. During the tour, I buttonholed a ninth grade girl, and asked
her, "What is the biggest difference between SEED and the school you
went to before?" Not missing a beat, she said that at SEED, a counselor
is knocking on your door several times a night to make sure you are
doing your homework. Back at her previous school, no one cared if you
did it or not. She had the look of someone who was learning good work
habits.
I’m not drawing any huge generalizations from one visit. What she had
to say about what her previous school did fit my preconceptions, though.
themail@dcwatch is an E-mail discussion forum that is published
every Wednesday and Sunday. To change the E-mail address for your
subscription to themail, use the Update Profile/Email address link
below in the E-mail edition. To unsubscribe, use the Safe Unsubscribe
link in the E-mail edition. An archive of all past issues is available
at http://www.dcwatch.com/themail.
All postings should be submitted to themail@dcwatch.com, and should
be about life, government, or politics in the District of Columbia in
one way or another. All postings must be signed in order to be
printed, and messages should be reasonably short — one or two brief
paragraphs would be ideal — so that as many messages as possible can
be put into each mailing.