Dystopian Dreams for Thanksgiving
Dear Dystopians:
Nathan Hurst, in Wired, writes enthusiastically of San
Francisco’s zoning revision that lops more than a hundred square feet
off of the overly expansive 330-square feet microunits planned for DC:
"Take That Tokyo! San Francisco Approves 220-Square Foot
‘Micro-Apartments’,"
http://www.wired.com/design/2012/11/san-francisco-micro-apartments/.
The Free Online Dictionary, dictionary.com, defines a dystopia as "a
society characterized by human misery, as squalor, oppression, disease,
and overcrowding." Our experts, our "urbanologists," want to build in
Washington and in America’s big cities a society of disaffected
singletons, alienated from others and isolated in cells that are the
size of and have the charm of storage units, in skyscrapers towering
high enough to block the sunlight from the streets. And they plan to
build that dystopian society deliberately, with foresight, because to
them overcrowding is a good thing, a positive value, that is opposed to
the dread "sprawl" that to them characterizes those dull suburbs and
underdeveloped cities that have too much green space and housing units
that are too spacious, and are connected by roads and cars.
Overcrowding, our experts claim, makes cities "livable" and "walkable."
It is what makes cities desirable. Pressuring people to give up their
cars, those societal evils that let them transport themselves
individually, when and where they want, and pushing them into public
transportation that takes them on the routes and on the schedules that
government plans for them, makes the dream complete. Overcrowding only
incidentally — and it’s not worth mentioning, so don’t bring it up —
creates the highest possible profits for developers and the greatest
possible contributions for their enablers, their kept politicians who
write the rules and regulations that make the dream possible.
But it’s Thanksgiving, that family holiday in which relatives and
close friends gather around a dining table (that’s too large to put in
any microunit, where lonely people eat alone, standing hunched over
minuscule kitchen sinks) and celebrate together. So it’s time to
celebrate that even the faddish enthusiasms of government experts can
eventually be tempered by reality. Kaid Banfield, "the director of the
Sustainable Communities and Smart Growth program at the Natural
Resources Defense Council, co-founder of the LEED for Neighborhood
Development rating system, and co-founder of Smart Growth America," has
written a smart and knowing article in The Atlantic Cities, "The
Urbanist Case for Keeping DC’s Height Restrictions,"
http://tinyurl.com/coux68t. Unlike most
urbanologists and smart grown experts who write about the District of
Columbia, Banfield writes from the perspective of someone who actually
likes this city and appreciates what the residents of its neighborhoods
see in it.
Banfield says that he wrote his article reluctantly and
procrastinated over it because he knew the controversy he would cause
among his friends and colleagues by defending the limitation on building
height. And he was right. Although there are some supportive comments on
the article, there are more highly critical ones. It will be worth
taking the time over your long holiday weekend, after you’ve recovered
from the Thanksgiving feast and after you’ve revived from your nap
following the Black Friday shopping contest, to read the article and all
its comments. This is the ground over which the urban planning battle
will be fought in the next several years, between the dystopian dreams
of the experts and the urban planners and the defenses of the
neighborhoods and residents of the city. Can the wisdom of the residents
protect us from the zealousness and fervor of the experts and the greed
of the developers and politicians? It will be a close call; the power is
not with the people.
Gary Imhoff
themail@dcwatch.com
###############
A Chicken Turkey in Every Pot
Dorothy Brizill,
dorothy@dcwatch.com
If ever you wanted insight into the workings of the District
government and many of the issue and problems plaguing it, then this
past Tuesday provided a good snapshot. First, on Tuesday morning,
Councilmembers Marion Barry and Vincent Orange, two of the most
ethically challenged members of the council, gave away holiday turkeys
to needy District residents and the politically connected. When queried
on Monday, Barry initially refused to reveal who had paid for the
turkeys and whether any of the donors were also DC government
contractors. He further compounded the controversy by claiming that
"only liberal white folks" are interested in disclosure and other good
government initiatives. By Tuesday, however, Barry’s office released a
statement indicating that the two thousand turkeys cost forty thousand
dollars, and had been paid for by a laundry list o companies with
contracts or ties to the DC government — Chartered Health Plan (which
was founded by shadow campaign financier Jeffrey Thompson), Wal-Mart
(which is seeking to open six stores in the District in the coming
years), Intralot (the Greek company that holds the District’s
controversial lottery contract), W.C. Smith, United Healthcare (a
managed care organization contracted by the District government),
Chapman Development, Fort Myer Construction (which is the single largest
contractor with the DC Department of Transportation), and Union Temple
Baptist Church (which provided the facility and staff for Mayor Gray’s
"shadow" 2010 campaign).
Meanwhile, across town in Ward 5, Vincent Orange’s council staff and
campaign workers distributed three hundred turkeys at Orange’s campaign
headquarters on South Dakota Avenue. The turkeys arrived at
approximately 11:00 a.m. in an eighteen-wheeler truck. As people lined
up to receive their turkeys, Anita Bonds, the Chairman of the DC
Democratic Party who is running for the party to appoint her to the
at-large council seat vacated by Phil Mendelson when he won election to
the Council Chairman seat vacated by Kwame Brown, planted herself at the
front door of the small building. Bonds is Corporate Relations Director
for Fort Myer Construction; she made certain that everyone knew that she
had provided the turkeys and that they had been paid for by Fort Myer.
To drive that message home, labels were placed on the turkeys reading,
"Wishing you and your family a Happy Thanksgiving. From Fort Myer
Construction Company in cooperation with DC At-Large Councilmember
Vincent Orange." In an effort to gain maximum personal advantage from
the situation, Bonds engaged in extreme politicking. She approached
turkey recipients and had them sign her nominating petition, which has
to be submitted to the DC Democratic State Committee with two hundred
signatures by next week on November 28. If an individual refused to
sign, Bonds would threaten to take back "her" turkey.
Footnote: on Tuesday afternoon, when I approached Vincent Orange at
the Wilson Building and asked him about the turkey giveaway, he refused
to answer any questions, and raced down the corridor to his office. He
wouldn’t disclose the total number of turkeys or whether they were being
funded by his constituent services fund or were being donated (which I
already knew from going to the distribution at his campaign headquarters
and talking with his staff). He did indicate that it was possible that
some turkeys were being donated, but he claimed he didn’t know the
source of the donation. I tried to impress on Mr. Orange the inherent
danger of pretending to be uninformed regarding the source of such an
expensive shrugged gift. He was agitated by my making inquiries, and
just shrugged his shoulders and said he was aware of DC reporting
requirement, and that it would be accounted for in the next filing of
his constituent services fund.
###############
Campaign Financing
Jacqueline R. Mitchell,
jacquelinerm@msn.com
[Re: "Clean Elections in the District," November 18] Why do we expect
this process to benefit anyone other than those who write and approve
the rules and regulations? Especially if they may eventually be the
recipients of the repercussions of the laws, rules/regulations. How many
unbiased community members were involved in the total process? Is this
the same as the criminals writing the laws for themselves?
###############
themail@dcwatch is an E-mail discussion forum that is published
every Wednesday and Sunday. To change the E-mail address for your
subscription to themail, use the Update Profile/Email address link
below in the E-mail edition. To unsubscribe, use the Safe Unsubscribe
link in the E-mail edition. An archive of all past issues is available
at http://www.dcwatch.com/themail.
All postings should be submitted to themail@dcwatch.com, and should
be about life, government, or politics in the District of Columbia in
one way or another. All postings must be signed in order to be
printed, and messages should be reasonably short — one or two brief
paragraphs would be ideal — so that as many messages as possible can
be put into each mailing.
|