Incompetence
Dear Competent Citizens:
In the last issue of themail, Ed Barron offered to bet anyone that
the Tenley Branch Library would not be built and opened before 2011.
Three readers respond in this issue, but so far no one has taken the
bet. Betting against the efficiency and competence of DC government is
pretty much a safe bet. But Ed’s lack of faith that the city
government will rebuild the branch library in a timely fashion is
inconsistent with his touching faith that the city government can
efficiently, competently, and effectively engage in "private-public
partnerships" to build government or mixed-use buildings, to
improve neighborhoods, and to encourage economic development.
Government is usually the least effective way to accomplish anything,
but it is particularly bad at building projects that are done under the
rationale of "economic development." There are two major
reasons for this: government officials aren’t punished when economic
development projects go wrong, and they are rewarded even when these
projects are done very badly. A private development company that makes
consistently bad decisions, that underestimates its costs and can’t
meet its construction schedules, will soon go bankrupt and go out of
business. Therefore, companies that want to survive will choose projects
that make economic sense, that they can accomplish within their budgets
and in a timely fashion.
Government doesn’t face the same constraints. A government that
makes repeated development mistakes will simply raise taxes or issue
bonds to pay for its miscalculations. The politicians who make these
mistakes, at least in DC, will not suffer at the ballot box; instead,
they will celebrate each other for all the hard work they did to raise
the extra funds needed to complete their misbegotten projects. The
baseball stadium was sold to the public with transparently phony cost
projections, and the electorate will not punish the politicians who
voted for it pretending that they believed these cost estimates.
Development of the many acres of vacant land in Columbia Heights was
stalled for decades by the city government’s bad decisions; even after
the government gave the land to its chosen developers a decade ago,
various parcels took anywhere from two to eight extra years to build as
developers renegotiated their contracts to get tens of millions in extra
subsidies from DC. No politician has suffered or will suffer for
choosing the least qualified developers for Columbia Heights projects,
for wasting taxpayers’ money on unnecessary subsidies for under
financed developers, or for delaying neighborhood development for years
and decades. Instead, when the DC USA project opens in another month (or
two, or more), politicians will take full credit for being the engines
that drove this "great economic development project" and for
revitalizing the neighborhood. They’ll be elbowing each other off the
dais.
Gary Imhoff
themail@dcwatch.com
###############
Fifteen Million for Lincoln’s Cottage;
Homeless Veterans Out in the Cold
Faye Pinkney, Faye515706@yahoo.com
There was an official ceremony Tuesday in recognition of the opening
of the fifteen-million-dollar restored Lincoln Cottage located on the
grounds of the Armed Forces Retirement Home. I was in attendance and
heard numerous accolades regarding the structure. Isn’t it ironic that
a building can gain the attention of many, simply because it was once
used by a former President, but fifty homeless veterans on the same
property are being "pushed out the door," and will be without
a place to live come March 31. Yes, this is what is happening right here
in America, "the land of the free, and the home of the brave,"
and in a nation that’s been blessed above all nations. It’s truly
sad.
What do we give priority? Cottage restoration or veterans out in the
cold? It’s not that both couldn’t be addressed, but veterans were
never even given consideration. To those whose choice it was to ignore
the cries of the people who have bravely served their country and
deserve a clean, comfortable environment in which to live: may you sleep
well tonight, in your better than comfortable bed, and arise tomorrow to
a fresh new day. Sadly, we are not as fortunate, as, by the grace of
God, we will awaken to another day of wondering where we are going to
live.
###############
Will Washingtonpost.com Follow CNN’s iReport?
Phil Shapiro, pshapiro@his.com
CNN has set up a web site where any member of the public can submit
photos, video, or audio of news they witness (see http://tinyurl.com/rwdqr).
Will Washingtonpost.com follow suit on this?
###############
Cabs Have Lost My Good Will
Jim Champagne, remyjec@aol.com
Having lived here for forty years, I have always been a staunch
supporter of DC cabbies. But not anymore. And it really has nothing to
do with the recent spate of one-day strikes. Maybe it is just me, but it
bugged me that some autocratic authority decided three times now to
institute a $1 surcharge for the poor cab driver who apparently can’t
afford gasoline.
First, I think a public hearing should have been held regarding the
extra buck for every ride. Since I take cabs at least twice a day (four
separate rides in all), that amounts to an extra $20.00 per week at
least. I’m not convinced that I should be paying the extra money for
someone who uses gasoline as an integral part of his business operation;
if he is getting $20 from me, then how much is he getting during the
course of a week? I believe that it is something that should be
discussed and not merely pronounced without citizen (riding public)
input.
Second, if the cabbies need the extra dollar for every cab fare, then
how can they afford to go on strike once a week to demonstrate their
collective displeasure over meters? Personally, I think the cabbies are
taking advantage of the situation, albeit a case where our erstwhile
mayor has no idea of what he is doing. Shocking on both counts. Simply
shocking.
###############
For months I have heard all of these transplants and visitors say how
outdated our taxicab system is and how it leaves one confused and
misguided. This is just another example of how the individuals in this
city and for that matter this country are completely on their heads. At
the current time, DC is one of the only places in this country in which
you can find out your exact cost of travel before you step foot into a
taxi. No guessing, no wondering if the taxi is taking the long way to
drive up the price of the meter, no questions about if you were hosed at
any cost. You see, we have this wonderful thing in this city called
information. To get this information, you can call the Taxicab
Commission or go on their web site, give them your starting point and
your ending point, and find out the exact cost of your trip, no matter
the cab company, time of day, or number of passengers. The same
individuals who can search Google to find naked pictures of so-called
celebrities, find sneak previews of whatever show or movie they are
looking for, or just more random information to complain about,
apparently can’t find the web site of the city that they are visiting
or live in, in hopes of making their life easier.
What type of example are we setting for our children? Yes, we know
that the information on exactly what we need to know is three minutes
away, but why do it the smart way when we can waste money? How will
these same individuals be able to tell a youth to pick up the book
instead of reading the Spark Notes or finding a summary online? How will
these same individuals be able to tell a young person that the work
ethic is important and that nothing comes easy, when they are the same
ones crying because taking three minutes out of their lives to do hard
work is just too hard? It baffles me that these same individuals wonder
why our educational system has only advanced to the point at which cash
registers at fast food places have pictures of the food instead of words
or numbers, wonder why our jobs are going overseas and why our economy
is going downhill faster than the career of Brittany Spears. Could it be
laziness, could it be the lack of work ethic that we instill in the next
generation, could it be outside forces that drive the global economy, or
could it be just us? How about for a day, just one, change your home
page from whatever it is to the web site of your local state government.
Take just five to ten minutes a day to read the press releases from you
locally elected leaders, and get a better understanding of the decisions
that are being made which most directly impact your life.
###############
Betting on the New Library
Sue Hemberger, Friendship Heights, smithhemb@aol.com
In the last issue of themail [February 17], Ed Barron called those of
us who are delighted to see the fate of the Tenley-Friendship branch
library disentangled from Janney Elementary School’s modernization
"loonies" add offered a bet that the library wouldn’t be
finished before 2011. Implicit in his bet was the notion that a
public-private partnership (PPP) would finish the project sooner. Not a
chance. If it’s a choice between Ginnie Cooper [Director of DC public
libraries] versus Roadside Development building the Tenley-Friendship
branch library, my money’s on Cooper. (If yours is on Roadside, you
might want to read up on the O Street Market project before laying out
serious money on this proposition.) Actually, if it’s a choice between
Cooper building a standalone library and any developer building the
library in the context of a mixed-use building that exceeds the zoning
limits and involves a couple of stories of excavation, my money’s on
Cooper.
What I don’t know, given the latest news — i.e., that developers
may present their original but now non-responsive proposals at the
community meeting on February 28 — is whether (and, if so, for how
long) Neil Albert’s shop will attempt to undo the decoupling of the
library from the rest of the project. If anything substantially delays
the library at this point, it will be that kind of maneuver.
DCPL has certainly screwed up big time in the past, but from what I’ve
seen of Cooper (and from her track-record building libraries (fifty or
sixty new and a similar number of modernizations)), I think she’s a
good bet. The submission deadline for DCPL’s RFP for a construction
manager at risk (who will lose 20 percent of his fee if the project isn’t
done on time and within budget by end of 2009) for this project just
closed last Thursday. Once that contractor is hired, the bet’s on if
Ed is still willing. But if DCPL is somehow prevented from making that
contract, I’ve got no confidence regarding what happens next. Never
underestimate DC government’s ability and inclination to snatch defeat
from the jaws of victory! The thing that people forget regarding the
public-private partnership is that it doesn’t get DC government out of
the mix. It would actually give more DC government actors, often with
potentially conflicting agendas, a say (or two or three) in the project.
At this point I have a lot more faith in DCPL (which has the money in
hand to build the branch and designs already drawn up), than I do in the
Office of the Deputy Mayor for Planning and Economic Development, DCPS,
the Zoning Commission, and the council, all of whom would necessarily be
involved in making the PPP happen.
###############
In themail of February 17, Mr. Barron comments on two activities not
wholly unrelated. I won’t accept his wager that the Tenley Library won’t
be rebuilt before 2011. I just wish its patrons godspeed in getting the
thing done. For me, the best news about that project is seeing the city
disconnect the library work from arguments over a proposed partnership
with the private sector to create much-needed housing in Tenley and, in
the process, accelerate planned improvements to Janney Elementary School
(which serves a neighborhood jam-packed with children and is bursting at
the seams).
Mr. Barron’s unfavorable view of a soccer stadium at Poplar Point
is, in my opinion, misdirected. Compared with the baseball stadium, the
soccer field is a sweetheart deal. I happen to believe Nationals Park is
a worthwhile piece of public work and will yield the benefits predicted
in that part of town — much as Verizon Center has on the East End.
However, it can’t be denied that Major League Baseball exploited
Washington’s lousy negotiating position and drove a harsh bargain on
costs and other burdens. DC begged more than three decades for a
baseball team and narrowly missed getting one at least twice. The
Nationals were our best (if not final) chance to land a viable,
established franchise. The unattractive terms we had to accept will not
prevent us from making a success of this venture. The soccer stadium is
another matter. First, its overall cost is much less than the baseball
stadium’s and, happily, DC will pay its fair share, not the whole
bill. Second, a soccer palace will almost surely anchor small businesses
and other enterprises already planned for that section of the eastern
river shore, helping to ensure commercial success in an underserved
community. By contrast, the ballpark precedes surrounding development
which, though likely to materialize, is only presumed to follow. Third,
and most important (in my view), soccer’s best days are ahead of it.
The game is supported by groups on the rise -- most especially, Hispanic
and other suburban families. Latinos are the fasting growing demo in the
nation. It is reliably predicted that, in just a few decades, one in
three Americans will be of Hispanic descent -- maybe more in this
region. Those folks love their soccer and will flock to Poplar Point
with money to spend and, frequently, wanting to buy homes.
What connects these two developments? One answer is this: the
prominence of "loonies," as Mr. Barron describes them.
Articles in the Post about the debate in Ward 8 over a soccer
stadium and other ideas for Poplar Point quoted some exasperated citizen
who said its opponents "are against everything." Up here in
northwest, I can sympathize. We hear -- loudly, constantly -- the rants
of obstructionists who reflexively oppose any and all creative
approaches by entrepreneurs trying work with government to meet the
public’s needs. Those folks love to recite, at nauseating excruciating
length, their interpretation of law and regulation but are markedly
uninterested in real action which that solve such pressing problems as a
dilapidated school or a housing shortage that is driving good people out
of the city. Mr. Barron’s gratuitous crack about Councilmember Barry
is neither here nor there. I carry no brief for the former mayor.
However, let’s give Barry credit for persevering in a climate of doubt
and trying to advance the interests of his benighted constituents. I
want someone like him representing me on the city council (hint hint,
Ms. Cheh) — someone willing to get behind sensible proposals for smart
urban growth — someone able to face down the reactionaries who
selfishly oppose reasonable attempts to change the comfortable order of
things.
###############
Loonies Win, Library Users Will Lose
Jonathan R. Rees, jrrees2006@verizon.net
In the February 17 edition of themail, Ed T. Barron states: "I’m
pledging to donate $300 to the new library if it opens by January 1,
2011, in exchange for a pledge by anyone, or any group, that will give
fifty cents to me for every day that the Tenley library opens after
January 1, 2011. Any takers?"
Ed, if history has taught us anything, it has taught us that nothing
gets done on time or any reasonable time therein. I am a betting man,
Ed, but not looking to go into bankruptcy. As such, thanks but no thanks
on your challenge.
###############
After more than ten years of analyzing the full range of DC’s inner
city problems that mar our US capital’s national and global image,
NARPAC intends to change direction for 2008. We have reluctantly
concluded that while it has been too easy for city leadership to
encourage economic development, even with ridiculous zoning limitations,
it is proving too difficult for even overpaid city officials to fix DC’s
Third-World socioeconomic woes without major inputs from beyond the city
limits. There will be a brand new gang in town in January 2009
(unfortunately without Tom Davis), and groundwork needs to be laid now
for increasing the federal focus on making the Washington region
(including its core city) America’s premiere metro area.
It’s time for top DC officials to stop misleading (dissembling,
really) about the freeloading of, or constraints imposed by, either the
feds or the suburbs. There will be a new opportunity to start
cooperating on a long-range program to restore national pride in America’s
capital. Fixing our capital city’s basic infrastructure, both human
and physical, requires national support and cooperation, not more
autonomy for local ideologues bent on remaining the region’s run-down,
go-it-alone poorhouse. We pursue these issues in NARPAC’s
now-quarterly editorial and in its, latest informal photo album
additions, which look at the conflicting symbolism implicit in DC’s
new baseball stadium and its surrounds (http://www.narpac.org).
###############
CLASSIFIEDS — EVENTS
Recorder of Deeds Building Tours, February 21,
23
Alexander Padro, padroanc2c@aol.com
The eighth annual DC Recorder of Deeds Building tours celebrate Black
history month. The District of Columbia Recorder of Deeds Building,
completed in 1942, features seven recently restored WPA-era Black
history murals (depicting African-American heroes including Benjamin
Banneker, Frederick Douglass, Crispus Attucks, Matthew Henson, and the
Massachusetts 54th Regiment) and other artwork, in a building designed
to house the only District agency led and staffed almost exclusively by
African Americans for over 125 years. Come visit the ROD Building and
hear about the history of past recorders of deeds, including Frederick
Douglass (the first Black recorder of deeds, appointed by President
James A. Garfield in 1881) and Blanche K. Bruce, the work of such
prominent African American artists as William E. Scott and Selma Burke,
and see the building’s intact 1940s décor, which was almost lost to
demolition in 2001.
The 2008 tours will be held on Thursday, February 21, at 6:00 p.m.
and on Saturday, February 23, at 12:00 p.m. The tours are free and no
reservations are required. The DC Recorder of Deeds Building is located
at 515 D Street, NW, just one block from the Archives/Navy Memorial
Green and Yellow Line Metro station and Judiciary Square Red Line Metro
station. Sponsored by the DC Office of Tax and Revenue/Recorder of
Deeds. For more information, call the DC Recorder of Deeds at 727-0419.
###############
National Building Museum Events, February 21,
27
Jazmine Zick, jzick@nbm.org
Thursday, February 21, 6:30-8:00 p.m. Engineering Series: The Past,
Present, and Future of the Panama Canal. The riveting history and
proposed expansion of the Panama Canal is explored by Dr. Michael J.
Brodhead, a historian with the US Army Corps of Engineers, and others.
$12 members; $12 students; $20 public. Prepaid registration required.
Walk-in registration based on availability.
Wednesday, February 27, 6:30-8:00 p.m. Washington National Cathedral:
A Century of Excellence in Architecture and Art. In celebration of the
National Cathedral’s 100th anniversary, The Reverend John A. Runkle,
RA, goes beyond the usual histories of names and dates to reveal that
the cathedral is more than just another building. $12 members; $12
students; $20 public. Prepaid registration required. Walk-in
registration based on availability. Both events at the National Building
Museum, 401 F Street, NW, Judiciary Square stop, Metro Red Line.
Register for events at http://www.nbm.org.
###############
eDemocracyCamp, March 1-2
Tim Bonnemann, tim@plansphere.com
I’m organizing eDemocracyCamp, an unconference (a
conference/workshop where the participants drive the agenda and
schedule) on e-democracy and related topics, March 1-2, in Washington,
DC. It’s a free, noncommercial, and completely community-driven event.
We’re trying to attract a diverse audience (political, government,
research, technology, as well as ordinary citizens). eDemocracyCamp will
be the first BarCamp with a focus specifically on e-democracy.
eDemocracyCamp will connect citizens, researchers, developers,
practitioners, and anyone else interested in the topic to learn about
the current state of e-democracy and share their visions for its future
direction. Topics may include (but aren’t limited to) e-democracy,
e-participation, e-government, e-voting, online civic engagement, online
political campaigning, online dialogue, and deliberation. Technical
tracks may cover things like the importance of open standards,
hacktivism, mashups, etc. For more information or to sign up, go to http://barcamp.org/eDemocracyCamp.
###############
themail@dcwatch is an E-mail discussion forum that is published every
Wednesday and Sunday. To change the E-mail address for your subscription
to themail, use the Update Profile/Email address link below in the
E-mail edition. To unsubscribe, use the Safe Unsubscribe link in the
E-mail edition. An archive of all past issues is available at http://www.dcwatch.com/themail.
All postings should be submitted to themail@dcwatch.com,
and should be about life, government, or politics in the District of
Columbia in one way or another. All postings must be signed in order to
be printed, and messages should be reasonably short — one or two brief
paragraphs would be ideal — so that as many messages as possible can
be put into each mailing.