That Was the Week That Was
Dear Newsies:
Metropolitan Police Department Chief Charles Ramsey announced that
the MPD would expand its policy of avoiding its law-enforcement duties
by refusing to enforce immigration laws any longer and giving a free
pass to illegal aliens (http://www.washtimes.com/metro/20030728-091925-3832r.htm).
DC residents responded with surprise that the MPD had still been
enforcing some laws.
Over the past few days, USA Today published a survey of
ambulance service in fifty American cities (“Many Lives Are Lost
Across USA Because Emergency Services Fail,” http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/ems-day1-cover.htm;
“The Method: Measure How Many Victims Leave the Hospital Alive,” http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/ems-day1-method.htm;
“Seattle: Firefighters, Medics Unite to Save Lives,” http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/ems-day1-seattle.htm;
“Washington, DC: Slow Response, Lack of Cooperation Bring Deadly
Delays,” http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/ems-day1-dc.htm;
and “How Fifty Major Cities Stack Up” database, http://www.usatoday.com/graphics/life/gra/ems/flash.htm).
The first article quotes Kenny Lyons, the head of DC's paramedic union,
as telling his loved ones “not to waste time dialing 911 if they face
a dire medical emergency. 'If they can find someone to drive them to a
hospital, drive them. If they can somehow catch a cab, go,' he says.”
DC Fire and Emergency Services responded with a plan to subcontract
ambulance service to Pizza Hut and Domino's, both of which promised
faster response time and a free medium pizza with three toppings with
every trip to the emergency room.
Mayor Williams, at his press conference today, blasted the City
Council for holding an emergency session to overturn his veto of their
bill eliminating the administration's badly managed program to use
credit cards for government purchases. “We've effectively eliminated
the Mayor's ability to do a pocket veto,” Williams complained,
expressing his dismay at the democratic principles of checks and
balances and separation of powers. (I don't even have to make this stuff
up: http://octt.dc.gov/services/on_demand_video/channel16/July2003/847.asx.)
At the same press conference, City Administrator John Koskinen
reassured DC patients that Greater Southeast Community Hospital will
continue to remain open and to provide substandard health care; that the
DC government will continue to monitor, document, and maintain that low
level of health care; and that the hospital "will not close
overnight," as long as continues to be profitable for the mayor's
political donors. Koskinen affirmed that, consistent with the
administration's policy of neither researching nor vetting either DC
government employees or the companies that do business with the
government, he and the mayor were unaware of and unconcerned that the
parent company of Cambio, the company now managing Greater Southeast,
had paid the largest fine in history to the federal government for its
Medicare and Medicaid fraud.
Gary Imhoff
themail@dcwatch.com
###############
The cost of living in DC is high. When compared to other states, the
city ranks third after Hawaii and New Jersey ( http://www.ded.state.mo.us/business/researchandplanning/indicators/cost_of_living/index.shtml).
In 1999, it ranked fourth among metro areas after New York City,
Oakland, and Nassau County (http://www.accra.org/edu_prof/pubs/coli_sample.htm).
Obviously, the cost of educating one's children would fall into that
high cost because of the number of factors that go into education. The
high cost of living, education, and socioeconomic status of most of DC's
public school children are among the reasons those children as a whole
have difficulty maintaining a top grade when the Nation's Report Card
comes out (http://nces.ed.gov/nationsreportcard/).
Obviously, states with school districts like those in Montgomery,
Fairfax, Orange, and Westchester Counties score better because of the
nature of their students' financial and economic resources.
But not all children in DC are economically disadvantaged. The
majority of white families in the District reside in Ward 3, where the
per capita income is roughly four times that of DCPS strongholds Wards 7
and 8. Almost 6000 children reside in Ward 3, which is over 80 percent,
white and a few thousand of those children attend DCPS (http://planning.dc.gov/documents/census2000/household/age_ward.shtm).
According to the Nation's Report Card, fourth grade white children in DC
public schools on average are scoring consistently in the top 20 percent
nationally, well above the national average. Those scores exceed the
average scores of Maryland and Virginia. But many of these children drop
out from DCPS after the fourth grade.
In spite of these high scores being published for the past ten years,
the city's leadership has consciously undermined public education in
Ward 3 by not investing more in its public schools in Ward 3. Since
1999, the city has provided tens of millions of dollars in tax-free
public financing to expand private schools in Ward 3 (http://dcbiz.dc.gov/info/rb2b.shtm).
This money went to building facilities and providing the bells and
whistles that everyone expects of private education. Simultaneously,
nothing comparable has been done to the public secondary schools in Ward
3 or the city. Tax dollars garnered through a commercial transaction
could have been used to create more attractive and enticing facilities
at Deal Junior High or Wilson High School. But the city's leaders would
rather Ward 3 parents send their children to an institution that charges
$15-20 thousand per year. The public schools lose students and the
resultant tax revenue based on the per pupil funding formula. Families
move out of the city because of the problems with the public schools.
More taxes lost. The Ward 3 parents who choose to stay in the city
refinance their houses to send their kids to private schools. DCPS loses
their political support, and the city loses its tax dollars in the
interest of special deals. If these deals sound like the baseball
stadium, they should. The real estate lawyers who give a lot of money to
DC's leaders also help decide what our schools look like. They then
write their costs into the revenue bond. And they end up making so much
money, the cost of living in DC doesn't seem high to them.
###############
Blaming the preventable deaths and the problems at Greater SE
Community Hospital on the closure of DC General's inpatient facilities
is understandable, but wrong. GSCH would be having these problems with
or without DC General's closing. If GSCH wasn't in the hot seat because
of its role as the provider of care for the vulnerable, you maybe
wouldn't hear about the problems, but they would still be there. Tufts,
the owner of GSCH, bought GSCH before DC General went into its death
throes. Tufts snaps up dying hospitals for the poor around the country
and squeezes them for all he can get. Tufts, we have learned, as David
Catania, (R, At-large), warned us, is what he is.
That being said, I object to any mythology about DC General. DC
General did get a high JACHO rating; however, the Public Benefit
Corporation, which ran DC General, was plagued with problems. The PBC
had a crumbling facility and no ability to bill Medicaid or Medicare;
thirty percent of the patients receiving free care (funded by DC tax
dollars) were Maryland residents, and administrators generously rewarded
themselves and the friends they hired with ever-increasing salaries
while denying entry level support staff raises for three consecutive
years. I ran a free medical clinic for five years (1990-1995) and we
couldn't get our patients into DC General except through the emergency
room. It was horrible.
GSCH and DC General both have had poor management and poor oversight.
Classic management for chaos, in city where those responsible to provide
oversight look the other way. Here comes the new boss, same as the old
boss.
###############
The Sports Commission
Dorothy Brizill, dorothy@dcwatch.com
This past spring, John Richardson, a member of Mayor Williams's
political inner circle, finance committee, and kitchen cabinet, resigned
as chairman of the DC Sports and Entertainment Commission, effective
August 1, in the face of substantial criticism from the public and the
City Council, a critical audit by the Chief Financial Officer's Office
of Integrity and Oversight, and a looming financial deficit for the
Commission. On Tuesday, Richardson convened his final meeting of the
Commission with the principal purpose of having the board approve a new
multi-year contract for the Commission's executive director, Bobby
Goldwater, whose $275,000 contract expires in November. After a lengthy
heated discussion in a closed-door “executive session,” the
Commission deferred action on Goldwater's contract when it became
apparent that there weren't enough votes to approve it.
With Richardson's departure, Mayor Williams must appoint an interim
chair of the Commission from among the remaining Commission members by
Friday. According to Council sources, Harold Brazil, who chairs the
Council Committee on Economic Development, which oversees the Sports
Commission, has confronted the Mayor and insisted that John Mahoney be
appointed. Mahoney is one of the newest and least knowledgeable members
of the Commission, having been appointed just last July. However, he has
a long history and relationship with Brazil. Mahoney was one of the Ward
6 residents who recruited Brazil from his job at Pepco for his first
campaign for the Council, in 1990. In the intervening years, Mahoney has
served as the treasurer of Brazil's political campaigns.
Several other Councilmembers are lobbying Williams to appoint instead
a political ally of Councilmember Jack Evans, William Hall. Hall is one
of the original members of the Sports Commission, appointed to it when
it was created.
###############
What Is the Mayor Thinking?
Ed T. Barron, edtb@aol.com
Or, perhaps, a better question is: who is he protecting this time?
The Mayor says use of the credit cards saves the District money. Has he
included the $200,000 the District has paid in interest because the card
users have not paid their bills and keep a large interest accruing
balance (http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A64714-2003Jul29.html)?
You know who is paying the interest on those accounts, you and I.
I made a very rational suggestion on a credit card program that is
based on issuing American Express cards that must be paid at the end of
each billing period. Those cards would be issued in the name of the card
holder with that person responsible each month to close out the bill.
The District would get copies of the monthly bills to ensure that all
purchases were legitimate and would write a check each month to the
individual based on expense vouchers for all purchases. That check would
be used to pay off the AMEX bill.
Perhaps the real problem is that many of the current card holders
won't qualify for the Amex cards. Do we want those individuals to have
cards for which someone else is responsible for paying the bill? I'd
sooner give Willie Sutton the key to my safe deposit box.
###############
DC Democracy and Gun Control
Parisa Norouzi, Washington Innercity Self Help, parisa@wishdc.com
Please take a moment to stand up against the latest attack against DC’s
gun control laws and attempt to exploit our lack of statehood. Go to the
link below to access an online petition against Senator Hatch's (R-UT)
senate bill # S.1414, the so-called “District of Columbia Personal
Protection Act.” Senator Hatch's office phone number is 224-5251.
Please take a moment to call and sign the petition, and encourage anyone
you know, especially in Utah, to do the same: http://www.petitiononline.com/s1414/petition.html.
###############
In Gary Imhoff's commentary on the commuter tax legal argument, he
misses the point by incorrectly stating that the argument is the oft
cited “taxation without representation” mantra. It is not. The
lawyers in the case realize that it is not per se unlawful to have
taxation without representation where the taxed entity is taxed in a
discriminatory manner. Because DC is the only jurisdiction
congressionally barred from taxing income at its source, its residents
are not treated on an equal basis as other citizens. Supreme Court
precedent has held that it is unconstitutional to tax individuals in a
discriminatory manner when those persons are not represented in the
legislature. Therefore, the argument is more accurately described as
"No discriminatory taxation without representation." The
difference may seem subtle, but it carries with it a substantially
different legal theory.
Lawyers have long been known to say "When you don't have the
facts, argue the law. And when you don't have the law, argue the
facts." In this case, opponents of the lawsuit have neither the
facts nor the law. They attempt, however, to argue the facts by raising
the red herring of alleged mismanagement of District funds as a
rationale for denying the right to tax. The constitutional rights of
DC's residents are not predicated on DC's management of money, its
choice of elected officials or any other factor. The naysayers of
Maryland and Virginia attempt to erect all sorts of bogus tests and
conditions to avoid addressing the fundamental issue of fairness. If
your employer paid you only 75 percent of what you were entitled to
because you had a penchant for wasting your salary and showed poor money
management skills, would that be acceptable? Of course not; the issues
are not related. You are supposed to get what you are due, and then do
with it what you will. The situation is the same here. If DC wants to
elect Kermit the Frog as mayor and then declare each Monday, Wednesday,
and Friday an official holiday, so be it. The rights of its citizens are
no less valid because of the choices that they may choose to make. If we
allow individuals in Maryland and Virginia to deny equal rights to DC
because of what they allegedly think of DC on a personal level, they
will forever protect their pecuniary interests while coming up with
nothing but more excuses for the inexcusable.
[I simply reported that the plaintiffs in the lawsuit said at the
press conference that DC should be able to tax suburbanites because
taxation without representation was unconstitutional. If Mr. Battle
believes that misrepresents the point of the lawsuit, then his argument
is with the plaintiffs. — Gary Imhoff]
###############
I agree that if the Mayor and Councilmembers and other officials are
serious about saving money and setting an example, they should take a
pay cut. Collecting and spending more money is not the key issue; using
funds appropriately and cutting waste and inefficiency are more
important. This includes holding officials to a high standard of
integrity, both personally and professionally.
###############
The Hickenlooper Cut
Margaret Feldman, mefeldman@aol.com
Great idea! They are quick to cut teachers and other low-level people
— why not themselves?
###############
CLASSIFIEDS — EVENTS
Gilbert and Sullivan’s Mikado Set in DC,
July 31 and Following
Jonathan Darr, movement@starpower.net
The Capitol Hill Arts Workshop and the GLBT Arts Consortium are
presenting The Mikado (as set in Titipu, Washington, DC, sometime next
week). This rendition of The Mikado has several unique twists! With a
little “No Taxation Without Representation” for good measure and an
invading band of Texans, this is one not to miss for any DC resident!
Shows are Thursday, July 31 through August 2 and again August 7-9 at
7:30 p.m. Tickets are: $15 and are available by calling the Capitol Hill
Arts Workshop at 547-6839. The show is at the Capitol Hill Arts Workshop
on the corner of 7th and G Streets, SE (a three-minute walk from the
Eastern Market Metro). The Arts Workshop is a nonprofit arts education
center for adult and youth classes, performances, and exhibits. The GLBT
Arts consortium is a voluntary collaboration of varied arts
organizations from the Washington, DC, metro area.
###############
Bone and Organ Donation Program, August 1
Barbara Riberts, barbara202@aol.com
On Friday, August 1, there will be a special program held at the
Martin Luther King, Jr., Memorial Library. The Technology Division will
be sponsoring a program presented by National MOTTEP on National
Minority Donor Awareness Day to present information on the importance of
bone and organ donation. At 10 a.m. there will be a proclamation from
Mayor Williams, from 12:001:00 p.m. lectures and demonstrations in the
main lobby. From 10:30 a.m.-12:00 p.m. and 1:00-3:00 p.m. there will be
health screenings that will include blood pressure (afternoon) and
cholesterol testing (morning). There will also be a number of exhibits
on the subject.
The library is located at 901 G Street, NW, between Metro Center and
Gallery Place. It has limited parking available on a first come first
served basis. For further information, contact Bartbara Riberts in the
Technology Division, Martin Luther King, Jr., Memorial Library,
telephone 727-1175.
###############
Expanding the Franchise, August 4
Parisa Norouzi, parisa@wishdc.org
Professor Jamin Raskin, American University, will speak on the
history, constitutionality, and politics of granting non-citizens the
right to vote in local elections, sponsored by The Voting Rights for ALL
DC Coalition, on Monday, August 4, from 6:30-8:30 p.m., at the Latin
American Youth Center, 1419 Columbia Road, NW, one block from the
Columbia Heights Metro station. For translation services please call
ahead. Contact Olivia or Dave at 483-4165 for more information.
A constitutional law professor at American University and author of a
leading article on non-citizen voting in the University of Pennsylvania
Law Review, Professor Raskin will discuss the experience of Takoma Park,
Maryland in enacting non-citizen voting and the current movement in
other parts of the country to "share the vote." Professor
Raskin is a noted constitutional authority and best-selling author of
numerous works, including We the Students, The Wealth Primary,
and Overruling Democracy.
###############
Capital City Public Charter School Community Block Party, August 9
Sue Bell, bellsue@aol.com
Capital City Public Charter School will have a community block party
on Saturday, August 9, from 11 a.m. to 2 p.m. (rain date Sunday, August
10), at the Columbia Heights Community Marketplace, southwest corner of
14th and Irving Streets, NW, next to the Metro. Free activities for
kids, moon bounce, music and entertainment, food vendors.
###############
CLASSIFIEDS — FOR SALE
Four Dining Chairs
Rob Pegoraro, robp at speakeasy.org
Four Crate & Barrel dining chairs with pine ladderback frames and
wicker seats. In great condition. The set cost me $400 new, but it's
yours for $200. 703-217-0493 or robp at speakeasy.org.
###############
CLASSIFIEDS — HOUSING
Writer’s Waterfront Retreat for Sale
Phil Greene, pgreene@doc.gov
“Chez When,” the waterfront retreat of the late Philip H. Love, Washington
Star editor, syndicated columnist (“Love on Life”) and Andrew
Mellon biographer, is on the market. Near Piney Point, MD. Here is the
listing: http://www.realtor.com/Prop/1029284886.
###############
CLASSIFIEDS — HELP WANTED
Bilingual Legal Secretary
Jon Katz, jon at markskkatz dot com
Silver Spring's Marks & Katz, LLC, seeks a full-time legal
secretary who speaks and writes flawless Spanish and English, and who
will accurately interpret and translate between the two languages. This
position requires successful prior secretarial experience; working well
and thriving under tight deadlines and high pressure; strong caring for
our clients and for quality work; strong communications skills;
flexibility and strong interest in learning new types of work;
intelligence and strong common sense; and independence. Pluses to your
application are prior legal experience, a college degree or demonstrated
similar intellectual achievement, current daily experience speaking
Spanish, and prior experience translating and interpreting between
Spanish and English. Ideal for people seeking rewarding work for justice
and individuals, and substantial client interaction. Please apply with a
one-page resume, strong cover letter specifically addressing your
strengths for and interest in this position (designating “Full-Time
Bilingual Legal Secretary”), relevant reference letters or a list of
relevant references, and salary history and pay preference to Jon Katz,
Marks & Katz, LLC, 1400 Spring St., Suite 410, Silver Spring, MD
20910. Fax: 301-495-8815. Please do not send E-mail attachments. For
more information, visit http://www.markskatz.com.
###############
CLASSIFIEDS — SERVICES
Mature writer, nonsmoker, extremely honest and reliable. I know what
is important regarding your home's safety and security while you are
gone. I am very clean and neat and would not entertain in your home.
331-4418.
###############
CLASSIFIEDS — RECOMMENDATIONS
Any Ideas for Dealing with the Invasion of Little Ants?
Phil Shapiro, pshapiro@his.com
Does anyone have ideas for dealing with the invasion of little ants
that some of us endure? I'm about ready to rent an aardvark from the
National Zoo for a week or two. What delight I'd have coaxing an
aardvark into my house and pointing out its waiting buffet.
###############
themail@dcwatch is an E-mail discussion forum that is published every
Wednesday and Sunday. To subscribe, to change E-mail addresses, or to
switch between HTML and plain text versions of themail, use the
subscription form at http://www.dcwatch.com/themail/subscribe.htm.
To unsubscribe, send an E-mail message to themail@dcwatch.com
with “unsubscribe” in the subject line. Archives of past messages
are available at http://www.dcwatch.com/themail.
All postings should also be submitted to themail@dcwatch.com,
and should be about life, government, or politics in the District of
Columbia in one way or another. All postings must be signed in order to
be printed, and messages should be reasonably short — one or two brief
paragraphs would be ideal — so that as many messages as possible can
be put into each mailing.