Common Sense
Dear Sensibles:
Yes, I have been rereading Thomas Paine, and thinking about some of
the principles behind the American Revolution. Here, for your reading
pleasure, are the opening two paragraphs of his revolutionary
best-selling pamphlet, Common Sense: “Some writers have so
confounded society with government, as to leave little or no distinction
between them; whereas they are not only different, but have different
origins. Society is produced by our wants, and government by our
wickedness; the former promotes our happiness positively by uniting our
affections, the latter negatively by restraining our vices. The one
encourages intercourse, the other creates distinctions. The first is a
patron, the last a punisher.
“Society in every state is a blessing, but government even in its
best state is but a necessary evil; in its worst state an intolerable
one; for when we suffer, or are exposed to the same miseries by a
government, which we might expect in a country without government, our
calamities is heightened by reflecting that we furnish the means by
which we suffer. Government, like dress, is the badge of lost innocence;
the palaces of kings are built on the ruins of the bowers of paradise.
For were the impulses of conscience clear, uniform, and irresistibly
obeyed, man would need no other lawgiver; but that not being the case,
he finds it necessary to surrender up a part of his property to furnish
means for the protection of the rest; and this he is induced to do by
the same prudence which in every other case advises him out of two evils
to choose the least. Wherefore, security being the true design and end
of government, it unanswerably follows that whatever form thereof
appears most likely to ensure it to us, with the least expence [sic] and
greatest benefit, is preferable to all others.”
Never goes out of fashion, does it?
Gary Imhoff
themail@dcwatch.com
###############
At DCPS, I wonder if they really do mean children first. At the John
Eaton Elementary School, the playground was covered in asphalt to
eliminate maintenance issues. (This was done quite a few years ago.)
This year the staff have taken to parking on the playground. Not only is
the usable space for children by a third, but this is a major safety
concern. When the drivers need to move these cars, there are lots of
little children running around that could be hit. Furthermore, the area
where the cars are parked is near the school which surely must be a fire
code violation.
After a myriad of complaints by parents, the principal said that
people can park there until noon, but then cars have to be moved. I
guess the children playing on the playground before noon have to just
avoid the cars. Other parents and I have observed staff driving off the
playground while children are present. We have written to and spoken
with the principal and the Deputy Superintendent, and I have spoken with
our school board representative. Nevertheless, the situation continues.
Cars and children do not mix. I am so afraid a child will be hit and
injured or worse. I am also at a loss as to where to turn to next for
assistance. By the way, there is plenty of on-street, non-residentially
zoned parking within a block from the school, admittedly down the hill.
###############
Reservation 13 Power Grab
Dorothy Brizill, dorothy@dcwatch.com
On Tuesday, the City Council's Committee of the Whole held a public
hearing to “review the Mayor's submission of the Draft Master Plan,
dated March 31, 2002, for the 67 acres of public land known as
Reservation 13, the existing site of the DC Jail and the DC General
Hospital.” The draft plan was developed by the DC Office of Planning
pursuant to specific provisions in the DC budget for FY 2002 (DC Public
Law 107-96 and H.R. 2944). The Congressional bill states that, “the
Mayor shall present to the Council for its approval, a plan for the
development of census tract 68.04” by March 31, 2002. (The draft
Master Plan is at http://www.dcwatch.com/issues/Res13-020331.htm.)
At the hearing, Office of Planning Director Andrew Altman presented
the Council with a memorandum from the Corporation Counsel's office that
claimed that, “the Master Plan has no legal effect or significance and
that the Council does not have the legal authority to accept, reject or
modify that plan.” (The Corporation Counsel's memorandum is at http://www.dcwatch.com/issues/pbc020404.htm.)
The Corporation Counsel's arguments for this position are both novel and
farfetched. The memorandum claims that, since the Home Rule Act names
the Mayor as the central planning agency for the District and the Zoning
Commission as the authority that amends the zoning regulations, the City
Council's only role in planning is to approve the Comprehensive Plan.
Since the Comprehensive Plan is already approved, the Council has no
further role in land planning at all. Secondly, the Corporation Counsel
claims that, since the Council had not approved of the plan before March
31 (the date on which the Office of Planning submitted it), the
provision in the DC budget is moot, and the Mayor is no longer obligated
to submit any plan to the Council. The audacity of this power grab —
and the Office of Planning's assertion that the Council was irrelevant
to the planning process for Reservation 13 — so angered the Council
that even mild-mannered Council Chairman Linda Cropp admonished Altman:
“If we are getting ready for a fight, then I am willing to put on the
gloves.”
###############
My Day at the DC Library
Dawn Dickerson, Ddd668@aol.com
Can't remember the name of the person posting about security at the
DC Public Library, but I want to share my experience from Saturday, May
25. I entered the library around 1 p.m. through the parking garage
entrance and there was no security. I walked through the metal detector
with my keys in my hand, the device went off, and no one came to
apprehend me. I even stood around waiting in case the guard went to the
bathroom and after eight minutes no one came; so I left. So when I get
upstairs I say to the guard, “Do I need to go through a scanner or
anything again,” and she says, “No, just go on in. Well, I didn't
feel safe leaving my car knowing that no one was even going to be
present to look after it, but my car is crap so I lived with it.
But the real tragedy occurred in the Washingtonian Room. I was
sitting at the table tending to my business when this jerk decided to
join me at the table where he proceeded to masturbate in my presence.
(What's probably even more incredible is that I didn't make a scene or
anything. I simply got my items and left; I figured no one was going to
do anything about it anyway.)
So I share this story in the hopes that the security staff at the
Martin Luther King Library will do a little more to make the atmosphere
at the library enjoyable for its patrons by being more visible and
patrolling the reading rooms more frequently.
###############
Tidbits From The Washington Post DC
Poll
Mark Richards, Dupont East, mark@bisconti.com
The Washington Post conducted a representative telephone
survey with 1,007 DC adults on May 15-19 -- see http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/metro/daily/may02/0502dcpoll.htm
for full questions and data reported to date. Here are a few items I
found interesting:
Biggest problems facing DC today: when asked in an open-ended
question, “What is the biggest problem facing the District today, the
one you want the mayor to work hardest to solve?” crime tops the list
at 22 percent, followed by improving schools/education (18 percent). The
largest change from 2000 to 2002 is in housing cost/low income
housing-in 2000 that issue was not mentioned; today 14 percent said it
is the biggest problem. Three percent mentioned DC self-government/
representation in Congress as the biggest problem facing DC.
Dramatic rebound in support for statehood: support for DC statehood
has risen to its highest level since The Post first asked the question.
Today, 66 percent support DC becoming a separate state, up a dramatic 20
percentage points since a low point in 1997, and up 8 percentage points
from the previous high of 58 percent in 2000. [Question: Do you favor or
oppose the District of Columbia becoming a separate state? Favor 66
percent, oppose 27 percent, no opinion 7 percent] I expect that the
increase is associated with a turnaround in the perception that quality
of life in DC is not getting worse (it is either getting better or
staying about the same). In 2000, a majority said the quality of life in
DC was getting better for the first time since 1988 — that trend
continues even though there has been some erosion in those saying
“better.” I expected there would be erosion as the euphoria of new
leadership wore off. Today, 19 percent say the quality of life in DC is
getting worse (compared to 47 percent in 1997). Forty percent say things
are getting better in their neighborhood, 44 percent staying the same,
14 percent getting worse. Fifty-four percent said DC is generally going
in the right direction today (22 percent said wrong track). Overwhelming
support for equal Congressional voting rights: The Post asked
about “giving the District the same Congressional representation as
the fifty states, including two US Senators and a House member with full
voting privileges.” A large majority of DC residents (86 percent)
favor full Congressional voting privileges, one of the most popular
components of statehood. [Question: Do you favor or oppose giving the
District the same Congressional representation as the fifty states,
including two US Senators and a House member with full voting
privileges? Favor 86 percent, oppose 11 percent, no opinion 3 percent]
For comparison, in March 1984, during the campaign to pass an Amendment,
a poll by Community Connections Corporation (307 DC adults), found 77
percent supported “an amendment to the Constitution that would give
the District of Columbia voting rights in the US Senate and House of
Representatives.”
Closure of DC General has impacted a third of those who used DC
General: The Post asked two questions about DC General: 34
percent of respondents reported that they or someone in their immediate
family had been treated at DC General at one time or another. Of that
group, 35 percent said now that DC General is closed it is more
difficult to get medical care. Sixty-two percent said it hasn't made a
difference.
###############
Beach Road Closing for Bikes
Gary James, Shepard Park (or as we call it now, East
Chevy Chase), jamesgang@worldnet.att.net
Does anyone know the outcome a month or so ago, of the handful of
bicyclers that were/are attempting to close Rock Creek parkway (note, it
is a road, folks) to automobile traffic on weekdays? Except for rush
hours, these people are attempting to close off a major thoroughfare in
the city that isn't clogged with cabs, bad drivers, untimed lights,
gnarly red light runners, stumbling pedestrians, overheated SUVs, and
all other kinds of daily commuting nonsense. There was an ANC4 hearing
in February, I think, then we heard nothing. What's up?
###############
What Happened to the Odor?
Dawn Dickerson, Ddd668@aol.com
Can anyone tell me how come Blue Plains doesn't stink anymore?
Noticed it last weekend while traveling on 295 and was completely
amazed. We've smelled that stench for years! What was done to make it
stop? Not that I want it back; I'm just curious.
###############
DC, A Foreign Country
Ed T. Barron, edtb@aol.com
For those who feel that the District of Columbia is treated much like
a foreign third country (or worse) you might try a subtle protest. I
have placed an oval shaped sticker on the right rear corner of my back
car window. The sticker is white with a black border and the initials DC
in the center. This is very much like the stickers on cars that are
brought into the US from European countries that designate the country
of origin for that car.
###############
Endgame, and a New Beginning
Dorothy Brizill, dorothy@dcwatch.com
At today's press briefing, Mayor Williams announced the resignation
of Fire Chief Ronnie Few — eight days after Few actually resigned. He
gave no explanation for the delay, but not even members of the City
Council were informed of Few's resignation until a closed-door breakfast
meeting this morning -- and Williams said nothing then until
Councilmember Kathy Patterson pressed him on the situation at the Fire
Department. Few's brief resignation letter, dated May 21, mentions a
“detailed meeting” with the Mayor on May 20. The Mayor's letter
accepting Few's resignation is essentially a two-page letter of
recommendation that expresses “great admiration” for Few's work over
the past two years and fails to acknowledge any of the serious problems
that continue to plague the department (problems with communications, an
inadequate reserve fleet of fire trucks, deteriorating facilities, and
delays in hazardous materials training, among others). In a statement
released late this afternoon, Chief Few praises himself highly: “I
have been a dedicated, passionate, and effective District official.
DCFEMS has benefited enormously from my expertise in all areas.” (All
documents are at http://www.dcwatch.com/govern/fire020421.htm.)
After Few leaves, Mayor Williams will appoint an interim chief and
establish a process for yet another national search for a replacement,
probably led by another personnel search firm. Instead of acting
decisively when he could no longer deny that Few's resume contained
several falsehoods, Williams was indecisive for months, then kept Few's
resignation secret for over a week, wrote a glowing recommendation for
him, and now will allow Few to remain in his position for two more
months, until July 31. City Administrator John Koskinen also revealed
today that he is negotiating a severance package with Few that will
include a bonus financial payment.
Also at today's press briefing, Mayor Williams announced the
appointment of Herbert R. Tillery to the newly created position of
Deputy Mayor for Operations. (I reported on this decision in themail on
April 7, 2002.) Tillery is currently the Executive Director of the
George Washington University Center for Excellence in Municipal
Management. In discussing him, City Administrator John Koskinen said
that a national search had been conducted to fill the position, but
that, “We are grateful that George Washington University has lent
Tillery to the city, and now we owe [GWU President] Steve Trachtenberg
something.” Foggy Bottom residents should take note, since
Trachtenberg has never hesitated to collect on debts. In response to my
question, however, Tillery did agree to recuse himself from any and all
issues that might arise regarding the University.
###############
Not so very long ago, Dorothy Brizill raised serious questions about
Ronnie Few's qualifications. She raised them before he was confirmed by
a lazy City Council. One person, armed with what we must assume were
limited resources, was able to unearth fundamental weaknesses in Ronnie
Few's career, weaknesses that proved to be fatal, and weaknesses that
were all but invisible to the vast personnel apparatus of District
government. In the five years that I have been reading themail I have
been struck by how often folks criticize people who question the Mayor.
Ronnie Few and Dorothy Brizill, the odd couple who prove that one can
never ask too many questions. Thank you, Dorothy. Had seven Council
members listened to you, we would have been spared the embarrassment of
too much Few for too long.
###############
DC Historic Preservation Law Project
Luis Acosta, luisma@wizard.net
Forwarded from Jan Snyder Anderson, Georgetown University Law
Library, anderjan@erols.com: “May is historic preservation month, and
many states planned celebratory events. As the month is not quite over,
I thought it appropriate to call to your attention Georgetown University
Law Library's DC Historic Preservation Law Project, the web site for
which is at http://www.ll.georgetown.edu/histpres/.
“Georgetown is publishing on the web the decisions of the Mayor's
Agent for Historic Preservation of the District of Columbia. These
decisions issued by the Mayor's Agent had not been published anywhere
until now. Current decisions are being transmitted electronically to the
law library, where they are converted to HTML and PDF formats and put on
a web server. Older decisions have been scanned and made available in
PDF format, and attempts are being made to fill in gaps in the
collection. Very basic searching is available now, but indexes to the
collection of decisions are being created and will be made available in
phase two of the project. There are also pages of web links relating to
historic preservation law. We invite you to take a look, and to pass the
web address along to faculty members who may be teaching historic
preservation, to state offices, and to other interested parties.”
###############
I Want to Hear the Answers to This Question
Mark Richards, Dupont East, mark@bisconti.com
The mayor asked Congress, at the hearing regarding Voting
Representation in Congress for Citizens of the District of Columbia,
“How can you live, work, and enjoy the city without wondering why the
District residents are not represented as the constituents you serve at
home?” Read full text at: http://www.senate.gov/~gov_affairs/052302witness.htm.
###############
Mendelson’s Viewpoint: A Supporting View
Robert Hilton, Woodley Park, HiltonOP@state.gov
Paul McKenzie (May 27) faults Councilmember Mendelson for his effort
to strike language from the Budget Support Act that would have the
effect of delaying the Mayor's decision on Klingle Valley. The Mayor has
decided, for a number of very good reasons, not to pave Klingle Valley
and open it to vehicular use. The Mayor is right, and Mr. Mendelson is
right. Reopening Klingle Valley to traffic would have negligible traffic
benefits at surrounding intersections. At the same time, it would cost
in the vicinity of $4-5 million, for a short segment of road in Ward 3.
That sum could fix many other, more important roads, throughout the
city. Both the National Park Service and the National Capital Planning
Commission oppose rebuilding the road because of environmental concerns.
Indeed, it is doubtful that, under today's environmental standards, a
road could ever have been built in the valley in the first place.
We've been debating Klingle for too long now. Let's move ahead with
the Mayor's plan, preserve this green space, control traffic, and
safeguard Rock Creek Park. Thank you, Mr. Mayor and Councilmember
Mendelson, for your actions.
###############
Mendelson Stood Up For the Environment and
Taxpayers
Jason Broehm, Adams Morgan, jason_broehm@hotmail.com
Councilmember Mendelson moved to strike Councilmember Schwartz's
Klingle language from the Budget Support Act on the grounds that
attaching the language to the budget is a backdoor approach. He argued
that Council supporters of the road (Graham, Fenty and Cropp) should
instead offer free standing legislation, a clearer and more direct
approach, to try to reopen the road. Schwartz pitched the budget
language as procedural and uncontroversial in nature, and many Council
members seemed to buy it, but Mendelson recognized the hidden agenda
behind the provision and fought to remove it, though his motion was
defeated. This Council action does not force the Mayor into action as an
earlier posting asserts. It ties Mayor Williams' hands and will
effectively delay the implementation of his plans for a trail in Klingle
Valley. Road advocates, it would seem, are the ones that benefit from
the status quo because it keeps their hopes alive that they can reclaim
their sacred strip of asphalt through Klingle Valley for cars, not
people.
Mendelson understands that rebuilding Klingle Road would pollute Rock
Creek and result in the deaths of many mature trees alongside the old
road. Because of his keen understanding and strong support for the
environment, he is the only Council member up for reelection who has
received an early endorsement from Sierra Club. As one of the chapter
executive committee members who supported his endorsement, I have to say
it was an easy call. Beyond the environmental reasons for not rebuilding
the road, Mendelson recognizes that spending upwards of $4-5 million on
a .7-mile road in Ward 3 would be unfair to other parts of the city
where roads in desperate need of repair would go unfixed. And all this
for a road that the feasibility study determined would have a
“negligible” effect on traffic congestion at intersections near
Klingle Valley. Councilmember Mendelson's should be commended for his
leadership in protecting the District's environment and making wise
decisions with our limited transportation funds.
###############
What a Difference Four Years Makes
Richard Worthington-Rogers, Strngman20001@aol.com
Last week it took me fourteen minutes go through the DMV at 300
Indiana Avenue, NW, to get my tags renewed. I couldn't believe it. Thank
you Mayor Williams and Director Hobbs-Newman.
###############
Full Support for Boys Town Youth Residential
Care Facility
Jack Fletcher, Ocfletcher@aol.com
There are over 500 neglected and abused children (citizens of the
District of Columbia) living in residential treatment facilities
throughout the country. These facilities are very expensive and require
wards of the City to live as far away as Texas and Arizona. I find it
strange that citizens from Ward 6 would oppose returning a handful of
children to the Boys and Girls Town (B>) facility in southeast.
B> does not need to go to Congress to overturn the illegal Board
of Zoning Adjustment decision. Assuming that these homes are on separate
lots and will house no more than six children and not more than two
staff each, they are perfectly legal and B> will eventually
prevail in the courts. However, should B> elect to file for
“Reasonable Accommodations Under the Fair Housing Act,” 45DCR 8057,
the matter will be resolved in 45 days or less.
###############
Phil Carney, noting abundant trash on 18th Street, asked “What is
with the people of Adams Morgan?” As a resident of the strip in
question, my answer is that the businesses and guests, not the residents
of Adams Morgan, are largely to blame for weekend-morning litter. I
estimate late-night customers of a single-slice pizza place are
responsible for about half of our litter. Pizza Mart sells
preposterously large slices of pizza for $3, far larger than one can eat
while walking to the Metro or in the back of a cab. Unlike McDonalds,
which also serves food to late-night drunks, Pizza Mart does not have
any seats inside. Thus, patrons eat on hoods of cars or while sitting on
front steps. Trust me on this one.
While primary blame ought to be directed at the litterers themselves,
Pizza Mart is entirely responsible the lack of adequate trash
receptacles inside its store and on the surrounding sidewalks. Moreover,
I am repeatedly frustrated by numerous other businesses on 18th Street
who do little, if anything, to clean up the mess in front of their
establishments before noon. There are exceptions, of course, but while
the litter is not their fault, but it is their responsibility. As an
opponent of the neighborhood's alcohol license moratorium, I find it
deeply ironic that an alcohol-free establishment causes most of our
problems.
###############
This message is in response to Phil Carney's posting in the Memorial
Day issue of themail regarding the cleanliness of Adams Morgan in
general and the Marie Reed School in particular. As the ANC Commissioner
for the school and much of the 18th Street commercial corridor, my
response is twofold: many improvements have already been made to the
neighborhood and the school, and many are in the works.
Just in the past three years, Adams Morgan has seen many improvements
to its commercial main streets (mostly thanks to the Adams Morgan
Business and Professional Association as well as my former employer, the
Latino Economic Development Corporation — one of the “good CDCs”):
decorative street trash cans installed bearing the bilingual message
“Keep Adams Morgan Clean,” repainted streetlight poles (the only
streetlight poles citywide to be repainted top to bottom), colorful
streetlight banners, and upbeat ornamental lights that trumpet our
stores, restaurants, and nightlife. Unfortunately, the wonderful charity
group (Ready, Willing, and Able) that used to clean our sidewalks and
streets shuttered its DC office a couple of years back, but the city and
some merchants are doing a good job of filling the gap (although many
merchants still need to be reminded of their legal responsibility to
keep the sidewalk in front of their business clean). Also unfortunate is
that the neighborhood's Main Street revitalization application was not
accepted, but fortunately an on-the-drawing board plan for a Business
Improvement District for the neighborhood can take on other planned
improvement projects.
Marie Reed Community Learning Center has been a tougher row to hoe,
so to speak. While the school features a wonderful interior that
provides many unique spaces and much natural light to its students, the
nook-and-cranny exterior of the school looks as if it were designed for
the exclusive purpose of sheltering taggers, drug dealers, and other
criminals. Fortunately, through partnerships between myself, the
excellent Friends of Marie Reed organization, and other charitable
groups, we have been able to frequently paint over much of the graffiti
found on the school. More recently, however, the graffiti has come back
with a speed, intensity, and profanity that has shocked even grizzled
anti-graffiti activists like us.
Fortunately, thanks in part to a walk through of the Marie Reed
grounds that I organized involving School Board Chair Peggy Cooper
Cafritz, staff from the Department of Parks and Recreation and
Councilmember Jim Graham's office, the Friends of Marie Reed, and our
ANC, a longer-term solution may be on the way. As we speak, DCPS
security and facility staff are partnering on a plan to replace and/or
augment the school's existing exterior lights with an improved system
that will eliminate the shadowy corners that harbor the current
evildoers.
One unfortunate reality: the school is largely constructed of
unfinished brick, meaning that graffiti on these surfaces cannot be
painted over, and therefore must be power washed. The city only owns two
power washing trucks (one of which is usually out of order), so removal
of graffiti can take a frustratingly long time. Not to excuse the delay
— the city clearly needs a whole army of these trucks, and should get
on top of the problem. Just thought that some firsthand information from
the front lines was in order. But please don't stop coming to Adams
Morgan (if for no other reason, summer is coming and Chez Antoine at
2427 18th Street has the best ice cream in the city, bar none!)
###############
CLASSIFIEDS — EVENTS
Patterson Campaign Kickoff
Kathy Patterson, D-Ward 3, kpattDC3@aol.com
Please join me for my reelection campaign kickoff Saturday morning at
Oyster Bilingual School, 29th at Calvert, NW, two blocks west of the
Woodley Park Metro stop. See the first new school built in the District
in the last thirty years -- one built by a combination of vision, grit,
and persistence on the part of the Oyster community. Coffee and donuts
at 10:30; a short program at 11; balloons and yard signs for all!
###############
CLASSIFIEDS — HELP WANTED
Advisory Neighborhood Commission (ANC) 6B seeks a part-time
community-oriented office administrator/executive director. The
administrator will aid the ANC and Commissioners in the execution of
their duties including drafting letters, contacting government
officials, maintaining financial records, preparing reports,
representing the ANC before government agencies, meeting support, and
various clerical and office duties. $10-$15 per hour, depending on
qualifications. Day and evening hours required.
Qualifications: Typing, office computer skills, BA degree or
equivalent experience, and experience in grassroots community
organizations. Preference given to ANC 6B residents. Send information to
Kenan Jarboe, Chair ANC 6B, 921 Pennsylvania Avenue, SE, Washington, DC
20003
###############
themail@dcwatch is an E-mail discussion forum that is published every
Wednesday and Sunday. To subscribe, to change E-mail addresses, or to
switch between HTML and plain text versions of themail, use the
subscription form at http://www.dcwatch.com/themail/subscribe.htm.
To unsubscribe, send an E-mail message to themail@dcwatch.com
with “unsubscribe” in the subject line. Archives of past messages
are available at http://www.dcwatch.com/themail.
All postings should also be submitted to themail@dcwatch.com,
and should be about life, government, or politics in the District of
Columbia in one way or another. All postings must be signed in order to
be printed, and messages should be reasonably short — one or two brief
paragraphs would be ideal — so that as many messages as possible can
be put into each mailing.