Organiza.gif (1182 bytes)

Home     Organizations

Forward to April 2004 DC Voter —  Back to League of Women Voters home pageBack to February 2004 DC Voter

The DC Voter
League of Women Voters of the District of Columbia
Vol. 80, No. 3, March 2004

Making Our Voices Heard — Making Our Votes Count

733 15th Street, N.W., Suite 432, Washington, DC 20005
202/347-3020,  fax: 202/347-2522
Website: http://www.dcwatch.com/lwvdc, E-mail: LWVDC@aol.com

President's Message
Congressional Representation: DC Voting Rights Committee
National Program Planning
International Woman's Day Luncheon
Welcome New Members
Air Pollution and Health
Children at Risk Committee: Juvenile Justice
International Relations Committee: Turkey Subject of March Meeting
Is America Ready to Run a Fair Election?
Electronic Voting Machines and Voter-Verified Paper Trails
Affordable Housing Committee: An Inclusionary Zoning Policy for DC
DC Homes Needed for B & B
Transportation Committee: Budget Shortfall for Metro Needed
Feet First
Unit News
Unit Meeting Schedule
Member News
Recent Contributions
Membership
Calendar: March 2004
LWVUS National Convention Volunteer form

PRESIDENT'S MESSAGE

Timothy Cooper, a human rights activist and resident of Washington DC, spoke to the February 10 meeting of the Congressional Representation Committee about his work to draw international attention to the violation of the human rights of citizens of the District of Columbia in their lack of voting rights which are enjoyed by all other U.S. citizens. Our meeting took place the evening before a press conference at the National Press Club, where the Mayor joined Cooper and others to announce a ruling issued recently by the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights - a ruling which brings the moral authority of a major international organization to bear on the denial of representation in Congress to citizens of this nation's capital. For more about Cooper's work, see committee report.

I know a number of you along with other citizens around the country are concerned about the reliability and validity of our voting systems, especially about the need for a voter-verified paper trail, and much has been written. For an evenhanded League view, please be sure to read the article that conveys the statement of the LWVUS Board, adopted at its January meeting.

An article about inclusionary housing reaffirms a long held position of the D.C. League which supports "economically, culturally, and racially diverse communities... in all areas of the city". Please read this article, a timely one as the issues of housing receive attention in connection with the 2005 budget.

On a lighter note, merry voices filled the room at Iona House on February 12, as our members played games (Bridge, Scrabble, the Patriot Game, more). Thanks to Elaine Melmed, Mary Rodgers, Hope Marindin Joan Domike, Barbara Yeomans for their contributions of food. Special thanks to Liz Martin for her leadership in organizing this event, which produced around $900 as well as a lot of fun for the League and to Joan & Art Domike for providing the Patriot Game designed by their daughter. — Frances Gem mill, President

Back to top of page


Save The Date!

Thursday Evening
April 22, 2004
84th LWVDC Annual Meeting

at
David A. Clarke School of Law University of the District of Columbia
Watch for a separate Annual Meeting Mailing later in March.

Back to top of page


CONGRESSIONAL REPRESENTATION: DC Voting Rights Committee

On February 10, at a meeting of the Congressional Representation Committee of LWVDC, Tim Cooper, a human rights activist and resident of Washington, D.C., described his persistent efforts to draw international attention to the violation of the human rights of citizens of the District in the refusal of the United States to allow them to elect voting representatives to Congress, a right exercised by United States citizens everywhere else in this country. Our committee meeting, attended by nine members, was timely, coming on the eve of a press conference arranged at the National Press Club with city officials and Cooper, representing his organization "Worldright" to announce a ruling issued on December 29, 2003 by the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, an agency of the Organization of American States. The ruling said, "No other federal state in the Western Hemisphere denies the residents of its federal capital the right to vote for representatives in their national legislature." The ruling brings the moral authority of a major international organization -one the United States belongs to and helps finance - to bear on the denial of representation in Congress to citizens of this nation's capital.

In his comments to the Committee, Cooper encouraged us to continue our efforts for voting rights and self-government. He said we should work for complete equality, and not accept less than the full rights that are available for U.S. citizens elsewhere; that is, he supports the goal of Statehood, which would provide for two Senators and representatives according to our population.

At the press conference the following day, which was aired on local stations and included Mayor Williams, it was reported that Cooper said "This decision (by the Commission) represents America's Achilles' heel," "It strips the king of democracy of his robe." — Frances Gemmill

Back to top of page


NATIONAL PROGRAM PLANNING

Some thirty-three members attended the January Unit Meetings to discuss National Program Planning. This was the first step in a process that ends this June at Convention 2004, when delegates from across the nation will meet here in DC to elect new officers, approve a budget for LWVUS, and adopt National program for the next two years. Our members wanted to retain all current National League positions except the position on East-West Trade, which, with its reference to USSR, has been overtaken by events.

Since we are still Studying the position on Election of the President, our recommendation there will await the results of Unit meetings scheduled for February 17-19, too late for inclusion in this VOTER. Members proposed that we review and update the League position on Apportionment. Our first choice for a new study was Immigration, "a major problem that should be addressed in an even-handed, League-like way." — Sheila Keeny (966-1692), 3rd Vice President - National Program

Back to top of page


INTERNATIONAL WOMEN'S DAY LUNCHEON

Monday, March 8, 2004
12:30 - 2:00 pm

International Women's Day Luncheon will be held on Monday, March 8, 2004, from 12:30-2 p.m. at the Mayflower Hotel. The program is "The Role of Women in the Emerging Government and Society of Iraq." Nasreen Sadeek Barwari, Iraq Minister of Public Works is among the confirmed speakers.

If you are interested in attending, RSVP to 202-454-2101, or events@unicwash.org. Tickets are $35 each if reservations received by March 5. At door, price will be $40. Space is limited.

Back to top of page


Welcome New Members

Mary Lou Beatty
Laura Beaufort
Ann Bensinger
Carolyn Darrow
Gail Gorlitz
Jane S. Hart
Carol Herrera
Lucy B. Mallan
Alison Martin
Jennifer Smulson
Doris M. Wohlfort

Back to top of page


"AIR POLLUTION AND HEALTH"

March 18, 2004
Presented by LWV Alexandria

On Thursday, March 18, 2004 at 7:30 pm, LWV Alexandria presents "Air Pollution and Health" with speaker, Dr. Dudley F. Rochester, M.D. (Professor Emeritus, University of Virginia School of Medicine, Past President, American Lung Association of Virginia) at The Lyceum, 201 S. Washington St., Alexandria, Virginia.

Dr. Rochester, an internationally recognized pulmonary doctor, will present a 40-minute power point presentation on the latest findings on air pollutants and their impact on our health.

Back to top of page


CHILDREN AT RISK COMMITTEE: JUVENILE JUSTICE

March Units will look at Juvenile Justice issues in the District, perhaps from a new angle. Unit members will have an opportunity to use a sample case history to identify obstacles and remedies for the city's troubled youth.

The press has often described the system as broken, and every day the city accumulates fines for failure to comply with court orders for reforms. A Blue Ribbon Commission appointed by the Mayor in 2001 has submitted detailed recommendations for correcting deficiencies. However, little change has been implemented - the system continues to deteriorate.

Come to a Unit meeting and get the feel of what a court judge experiences when seeking to balance public safety and rehabilitation of errant youth. — Joan Wilson (237-6264), Chair.

Back to top of page


INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS COMMITTEE: TURKEY SUBJECT OF MARCH MEETING

The next IR Committee meeting will be on Sunday, March 21st from 2-4 pm, at Sheila Keeny's house. The topic for discussion will be Turkey. Sheila's address is 3600 Albemarle St. NW, and her telephone is 966-1692.

Our IR discussions have been very interesting and lively this year. If you haven't been to an IR meeting with our "salon" format, you might want to give us a try! — Susan Rao (636-1688) and Anne Porowski (364-0557), Co-chairs

Back to top of page


Is America Ready to Run A Fair Election?

On March 24, 2004, a luncheon will be held at 12 noon at the Women's National Democratic Club with the question "Is America Ready to Run a Fair Election?" Cheliie Pingee, President of Common Cause, and former Senator from Maine, will speak.

For reservations call 202-232-7363. Accessible via Metro: Red Line to Dupont Circle station and exit on 19th & Q Sts. NW. Walk East on Q about 2 blocks.

Back to top of page


ELECTRONIC VOTING MACHINES AND VOTER-VERIFIED PAPER TRAILS

LWVUS Board of Directors Issues Statement

Following its January 2004 meeting, the LWVUS Board forwarded the following summary of its current thoughts on electronic voting machines, suggesting that State and local Leagues include the statement below in their VOTERS:

The League of Women Voters strongly supports full and equal voting rights for all eligible Americans, including persons with disabilities. The League also supports voter verification of ballots, including the requirement in the Help America Vote Act (HAVA) whereby the voter verifies the ballot before it is cast and counted. However, the League does not support proposals for a new requirement for paper-based voter verification -- the voter-verified paper trail (WPT) system that would require Direct Recording Electronic (DRE) machines to provide an individual paper confirmation for each ballot for each voter to verify.

A WPT requirement undermines voting access for people with disabilities or limited English proficiency, raises costs, fails to guarantee security, unnecessarily complicates the voting process, undermines federal certification standards, and slows the replacement of outdated voting machines.

The voter-verified paper trail requirement undermines voting access. DREs make it possible, for the first time, for persons with visual disabilities or limited manual dexterity to cast secret and independent ballots. Because DREs can be programmed in multiple languages, voters with limited English proficiency can participate fully and equally. The millions of Americans who face literacy challenges also can take advantages of the audio features of DREs to cast independent votes without embarrassment. The WPT system requires the voter to verify the written paper ballot, which historically disenfranchised voters will find difficult to do if they cannot see or if they have difficulty reading the paper verification. The WPT requirement is costly and will also slow down the replacement of outdated voting machines or push election administrators toward optical scan ballots, which are less accessible to the types of historically disenfranchised voters described above.

The voter-verified paper trail system doesn't work. It does not guarantee a solution to the security concerns it is intended to fix. If an electronic voting machine can be programmed to record an incorrect vote, it can be programmed to print out a misleading confirmation. WPT advocates say the paper
confirmations can be counted, but paper ballots are notoriously difficult to count accurately. And there is a long history of lost, mangled, and manipulated paper ballots.   The real solution to security concerns is to institute the measures described below.

Management and operational procedures can be put in place now to protect voting machine security. Among these are: physical isolation of each machine to protect against "hacking"; maintaining election official control over ballot creation, source codes, and management systems; statewide security programs binding on jurisdictions; improved equipment management practice and polling place operations; testing prior to and after Election Day; and parallel monitoring during Election Day.

A WPT unnecessarily complicates Election Day processes for voters, poll workers, and election administrators. Printers jam, need paper, and are slow. With long lines already a problem of polling places, printing individual ballots and requiring a confirmation process for each voter will only exacerbate problems, confuse voters, and undermine voter privacy.

Federal standards already require that new voting machines, including DREs, provide paper records for recounts and authentication of elections.

The WPT requirement undermines the certification and standards process that protects voters and state and local governments. WPT systems are not certified. Mandating their use without a thorough certification process weakens the reliability of voting systems. — LWVUS Board of Directors

"The League also supports voter verification of ballots, including the requirement in the Help America Vote Act (HAVA) whereby the voter verifies the ballot before it is cast and counted. However, the League does not support proposals for a new requirement for paper-based voter verification -- the voter-verified paper trail (WPT) system that would require Direct Recording Electronic (DRE) machines to provide an individual paper confirmation for each ballot for each voter to verify."

Back to top of page


AFFORDABLE HOUSING COMMITTEE: An Inclusionary Zoning Policy for DC

Inclusionary zoning could make it possible for the District of Columbia to put much needed private dollars to work on building affordable housing. In spite of the District's progress in building low-and-moderate-income housing in the past few years, our city still has a deficit of affordable housing, especially for low-income working families. More than 24% of homeowners and 35% of renters are paying more than they can afford for housing. Indeed, some households pay as much as 50% of their monthly income on shelter. Where families live can be just as important as how much they pay. Residents in neighborhoods with high concentrations of poverty typically are cut off from jobs, good schools, and health services. They are also more likely to be victims of crime.

Building and renovating housing is expensive, and up until now, most low-income housing in DC has been financed by the public sector. But the public sector has not been able to keep up with the need, and the gap between the need and the supply of affordable housing continues to grow. For over 25 years, communities across the country, including neighboring Montgomery County, have been using inclusionary zoning (IZ) to build thousands of units of affordable housing with private dollars. IZ requires private developers to make a percentage of housing units in new residential developments affordable to low and moderate-income families. The developers. still make a profit, because in return, county and city governments give them such benefits as the right to build developments with higher densities. 

For over 25 years, communities across the country, including neighboring Montgomery County, have been using inclusionary zoning (IZ) to build thousands of units of affordable housing with private dollars.

Inclusionary zoning could benefit the District by:

  1. Producing affordable housing for its low-and moderate-income working families and by requiring that 15% of every development of ten or more units be affordable to households earning $25,000 to $68,000;
  2. Creating mixed-income communities city wide, which is very important in a city experiencing increased concentrations of poverty;
  3. Connecting residents of modest incomes to valuable housing opportunities; and
  4. Establishing firm and fair policies through which the private market can contribute affordable housing.

ACORN, DC's largest community organization of low- and moderate-income families, is heading up a campaign to get an inclusionary zoning policy for Washington.   We hope the League will join ACORN, WISH (Washington Inter-city Self Help), the DC Agenda, the Washington Regional Network, unions, and other organizations by re-affirming the principles of inclusionary zoning, and joining with these partners to persuade the Mayor and Council to develop a mandatory IZ policy. ? Janet W. Brown, Affordable Housing Cmte. with Pocohontas Outlaw, Chair, DC ACORN

Back to top of page


See the Capitol Steps Musical Political Satire for Free!

Be a LWVUS National Convention Volunteer
June 11-15, 2004
and you will have a ticket to the performance on Sunday, June 13th, 7:30 pm
in the Ballroom of the Hilton Washington Hotel
See the insert for further details.

Back to top of page


DC HOMES NEEDED FOR B&B: JUNE 10 - 16, 2004

As in previous years when the LWVUS Convention is held in DC, League members have opened their homes to out of state Leaguers as a Bed & Breakfast alternative to the hotel. The DC Leaguer provides a bedroom, access to a bathroom, and a light breakfast (coffee, tea, muffin). In turn, the League charges a daily rate that is split with the homeowner. The League uses this as a fundraiser and compensates the homeowner for the use of their home. If you have a spare bedroom and would like to participate, call Chris Matthews at 269-3890.

Back to top of page


TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE: BUDGET SHORTFALL FOR METRO PROJECTED

The Washington Metropolitan Transit Administration (METRO) plans to schedule hearings on rail and bus fare increases in the near future, to meet a projected budget shortfall in fiscal year 2005. Numerous cost cutting measures are being considered to expected income levels. Our transportation committee has been attending METRO board and committee meetings Wednesdays at 9:00 am.

Detailed discussions on the possible effect on ridership of various alternative fare and service changes. The recent fare increases have not affected ridership as much as had been projected, and ridership is now being promoted through a new program to post improved fare, schedule, and route information at street bus shelters and stops. An attempt to increase revenue by expanding advertising in stations, on buses, and in rail cars has been approved on an experimental basis, without public hearings or input.

Additional revenues might come from expanded "Metrocheck", now used by 150,000 commuters in the region. A bill has been introduced in the House of Representatives that would increase the subsidy available from the Federal government for transit from $100 a month to $175 ($190) per month available for commuter automobile parking.

Budget overruns are arising from unanticipated costs in pension and health care allowances. For the current fiscal year, total expenditures are close to the budgeted levels, even though pensions and health care costs are substantially over budget.

Among several cost savings proposals left for future decision is one to expend for operations the interest on a large joint development project fund that is being held for future project use.   The use of this accrued interest for current operations does not represent a settled policy, and David A. Catania of the District of Columbia received Board support in requesting further consideration of the policy implications of the proposal, prior to Board action.

While it is debating its options for meeting operating costs, METRO is also seeking support for a six-year capital improvement program to allow for increased ridership by the purchase of 120 rail cars and 185 buses, and to prevent further delay in essential system infrastructure maintenance.

The D.C. League testified before the DC Council Committee on Public Services on February 9 in support of this effort. METRO and the DC government and business community are united in hoping to secure important Federal funds for this program.

We need to involve additional League members in the effort to monitor the meetings of the boards and committees of METRO and the Transportation Planning Board (TPB) of the Council of Governments. The TPB usually meets on the third Wednesday of each month at its North Capitol Street offices, near Union Station. METRO meetings are usually weekly at the headquarters at 5th and F Sts. NW, half a block from the Judiciary Square Metro station. Contact Grace Malakoff at lwvp@aol.com, or 387-7540 and Pat Hallman at ephallman@starpower.net or 829-8852 for more information.

Transit schedules and routes are available at most Metro Station Kiosks or on line at http://rideguide.wmata.com, which will also help you plot your trip via bus, metro rail or both. — Grace Malakoff (387-7540) and Pat Hallman (829-8852)

"We need to involve additional League members in the effort to monitor the meetings of the boards and committees of METRO and the Transportation Planning Board (TPB) of the Council of Governments." Contact Grace Malakoff or Pat Hallman for more information.

Back to top of page


FEET FIRST

A first for the Federal Transportation Research Board (TRB) this year was the FEET FIRST gathering of bike and pedestrian transportation leaders from around the country. They assembled as a part of the annual TRB meeting, which is also breaking new ground by having at least one woman as a Board member - the member in charge of this program.

On February 11, the National Building Museum sponsored a "Ray Buden Showcasing of Projects" bringing new pedestrian and biking amenities to locations around the world, including Waikiki Beach. — Grace Malakoff

Back to top of page


UNIT NEWS

March Units will look at Juvenile Justice issues in the District, perhaps from a new angle. Unit members will have an opportunity to use a sample case history to identify obstacles and remedies for the city's troubled youth. See article on p.3 Children At Risk.

The Unit Council will meet Monday, March 8th at 12 noon in the LWVDC office, 733 15th St., NW — Joan Domike (966-3865)

Back to top of page


UNIT MEETING SCHEDULE

Tuesday, March 16

9:45 am, Southwest Unit will meet in the home of Anna Marsh (554-7719) 1253 Delaware Ave. SW
12:45 pm, Northwest Day Unit will meet at IONA Senior Services, 4125 Albemarle St., NW For info contact Frances Gemmill 362-6784
6:30 pm, In-Town Evening Unit will meet at the Irish Channel Pub/Restaurant (inside the Red Roof Inn) 500 H St., NW (near Gallery P1 /Chinatown Metro Stop). 6:30 pm social (you can choose to eat dinner or not/7:00 pm Meeting begins. Call Sheila Willet at 347-3020 or 5881734 for info.

Wednesday, March 17

9:45 am, Upper 16th St. Unit will meet in the home Madlyn Calbert (832-7630) 1261 Kearney St. NE

Thursday, March 18

9:45 am, Chevy Chase/Ingleside will meet at the Ingleside Theatre in the Apartments, 3050 Military Rd., NW. For info contact Joan Wilson 237-6264
7:00 pm, The Evening Unit will meet in the home of Gloria Liebenson (362-0867) 4200 Massachusetts Ave., NW Apt 615

Back to top of page


MEMBER NEWS

We are sad to call your attention to the report in The Washington Post on February 1 of the death of Anne Weinberg on January 29. Anne was an active League member from the Southwest Unit, and she chaired the Southwest Unit in 1978-79. We remember her presence among us, and will continue to work for the better government she valued. We extend our sympathy to her family. — Frances Gemmill

Back to top of page


RECENT CONTRIBUTIONS

We gratefully thank our members for their recent contributions: Marion Bell, Susan Carpenter, Ethel Cooper, Anna Course, Julia Cuniberti, Joan Domike, Frances Gemmill, Grace Malakoff, Anna Marsh, John Mathison, Paula McKann, Elizabeth Merritt, Kristin Moore, Abigail Nichols, Susan Rao, Kathryn Ray, Mary Rodgers, Jackie Russler, Lorraine Sinderbrand, Barbara Stout, Gladys Weaver, Sheila Willet, Joan Wilson, Elizabeth Yancey.

Back to top of page


MEMBERSHIP

Questions concerning League membership can be directed to Suzanne Campagna (338-1055) or Linda Softli (667-8210), Membership Chair

Has your League Membership expired? Please check the address label on the back page of this issue. If the membership date above your name has passed, print out the renewal form and mail with your check (made payable to LWVDC) to LWVDC, 733 15th St., NW, Suite 432, Washington, DC 20005-6020.

Back to top of page


CALENDAR: MARCH 2004

SUN MON TUES WED THURS FRI SAT
  1 2 3 10;00 am, LWVDC Board Meeting 4 5 10:00 am, NCA Board Mtg. 6
7 8 12 noon Unit Council Mtg.
12:30 pm Int'l Women's Day Luncheon
9 9:45 am Voter Registration of New US Citizens
Deadline for articles for April DC Voter
10 10:00 am Education Cmte mtg 11 12 13
14 15 16 Unit Meetings
9:45 am Southwest Day
12:45 pm Northwest Day
6:30 pm In-Town Evening
17 Unit Meeting
9:45 am Upper 16th St.
18 Unit Meetings
9:45 am Chevy Chase/Ingleside
7:30 pm Evening Unit
7:30 pm Air Pollution and Health
19 Annual Meeting notice mailed 20
21 2-4 pm IR Cmte Mtg 22 23 24 12 Noon Luncheon
Is America Ready to Run a Fair Election?
25 26 April DC Voter mailed 27
28 29 30 31      


Send mail with questions or comments to webmaster@dcwatch.com
Web site copyright ©DCWatch (ISSN 1546-4296)