Home
Bibliography
Calendar
Columns
Dorothy Brizill
Bonnie Cain
Jim Dougherty
Gary Imhoff
Phil Mendelson
Mark David Richards
Sandra Seegars
DCPSWatch
DCWatch
Archives
Council Period 12
Council Period 13
Council Period 14
Election 1998
Election 2000
Election 2002
Elections
Election
2004
Election 2006
Government and People
ANC's
Anacostia Waterfront Corporation
Auditor
Boards and Com
BusRegRefCom
Campaign Finance
Chief Financial Officer
Chief Management Officer
City Council
Congress
Control Board
Corporation Counsel
Courts
DC2000
DC Agenda
Elections and Ethics
Fire Department
FOI Officers
Inspector General
Health
Housing and Community Dev.
Human Services
Legislation
Mayor's Office
Mental Health
Motor Vehicles
Neighborhood Action
National
Capital Revitalization Corp.
Planning and Econ. Dev.
Planning, Office of
Police Department
Property Management
Public Advocate
Public Libraries
Public Schools
Public Service Commission
Public Works
Regional Mobility Panel
Sports and Entertainment Com.
Taxi Commission
Telephone Directory
University of DC
Water and Sewer Administration
Youth Rehabilitation Services
Zoning Commission
Issues in DC Politics
Budget issues
DC Flag
DC General, PBC
Gun issues
Health issues
Housing initiatives
Mayor’s mansion
Public Benefit Corporation
Regional Mobility
Reservation 13
Tax Rev Comm
Term limits repeal
Voting rights, statehood
Williams’s Fundraising Scandals
Links
Organizations
Appleseed Center
Cardozo Shaw Neigh.Assoc.
Committee of 100
Fed of Citizens Assocs
League of Women Voters
Parents United
Shaw Coalition
Photos
Search
What Is DCWatch?
themail
archives
|
THE CASE AGAINST CONTRACTING WITH DOCTORS
COMMUNITY HEALTHCARE CORPORATION (DCHC)
By Councilmember David Catania (At-Large)
The following items are a collection of published accounts regarding Doctors Community
Healthcare Corporation (DCHC). At present, the Control Board is in the process of
negotiating an agreement with DCHC to take over operations of the PBC, including DC
General Hospital. Given DCHC's record, I believe that it would be unwise to entrust one of
our most important institutions to this company.
Among the most serious allegations and concerns include:
1. DCHC, a for-profit company, is deeply in debt and unprofitable;
2. DCHC has a reputation for its inability to complete deals and for 11th hour demands in
negotiations.
Consider the following published accounts:
I. DCHC'S FINANCIALHISTORY IS EXTREMELY WEAK. MOREOVER, THERE IS NO EVIDENCE THAT
DCHC'S FINANCIAL SITUATION HAS IMPROVED.
Doctors CommunityHealthcare Corp. (DCHC) is strapped for cash, is carrying a huge debt
and has posted steep annual losses for the last three years. . . .. In this years
first half, the company reported a $2.6 million loss before taxes on revenues of $60.5
million. In 1997, it posted a $17 million loss before taxes onrevenues of $109.3 million.
The company did not provide after-tax figures for last year. The $17 million loss
includes a $5.5 million loss attributed to changes in Medicare and Medicaid reimbursements
and unpaid property taxes in prior years at the companys hospital in Washington,
D.C. In 1996 and 1995, DCHC reported loses of $3.6 million and $3.3 million,
respectively. Restated 1995 financial results following an audit by Ernst
&Young LLP show that DCHC had overstated revenues by $2.3 million. The company
currently has long-term debt of $123 million which excludes debt from the
Reese/Grant transaction. DCHCs total shareholder equity is a negative $22.2 million,
pushing its debt-to-capitalization ratio to a whopping 122% -- a sign of an overleveraged
company with minimal financial flexibility.Crains Chicago Business, October
12, 1998, Pg. 1 (emphasis added). As a privately-held corporation, DCHC does not file
standard corporate reports with the Securities and Exchange Commission -- such as 10-Ks.
As such, it is nearly impossible to perform due-diligence into their finances.
II. DCHC & GREATER SOUTHEAST COMMUNITYHOSPITAL: 11TH HOUR NEGOTIATING PRACTICES
(1999).
A. DCHC backed out of the original deal only an hour before its announcement.
Washington,D.C. based Greater Southeast Community Hospital officials were
shocked yesterday when Arizona-based Doctors Community Healthcare Corp.
withdrew its $39 million offer to buy the hospital and its affiliates only an hour
before the deal was to be announced in bankruptcy court the Washington Post
reports. Doctors Community officials said that they were blindsided by
last-minute financial disclosures filed by the near-bankrupt Washington, D.C. hospital,
which included reports that state and federal officials are trying to recover $4.6 million
in overpayments. Doctors Community officials also complained about major
discrepancies in the hospitals inventory of shared and leased medical
equipment, but made clear that they hope to negotiate a new deal with the hospital today.
Greater Southeast, currently facing a $70 million debt, has until tomorrow to
secure a partner or will face a court-ordered liquidation of all of its assets. AmericanHealth
Line, November 4, 1999 (emphasis added).
B. With Greater Southeast Community Hospital's back against the wall, DCHC purchased
the hospital for much less than originally agreed upon. "National Century Financial
Enterprises, Dublin, Ohio, provided $30 million in financing to Doctors Community
Healthcare Corp., Scottsdale, Ariz., for its acquisition of Greater Southeast Community
Hospital in Washington. The deal was completed Dec. 31. The agreement provided for
accounts receivable, equipment financing and real estate bridge commitments for the $22.3
million purchase with more funding available for closing costs and working capital". Modern
Healthcare, February 28, 2000, Pg. 52.
C. DCHC continues to seek financial advantages from the District. "Paul Tuft, the
CEO of Doctors Community Healthcare, proposed a 20 year property tax exemption at the
beginning of 2000, soon after Doctors Community purchased Greater Southeast at a
bankruptcy sale. The tax exemption could be worth nearly $1 million a year." Washington
Post, January 23, 2001, Pg. B5 (emphasis added).
D. After the purchaseof Greater Southeast, DCHC downsized Hadley. "The company
that owns the two District hospitals east of the Anacostia River said yesterday that it
will consolidate emergency and general medical services at the larger one and convert the
other into a nursing home and long-term acute care facility. Hadley Memorial Hospital will
close its emergency room Feb. 1 and send such cases to Greater Southeast Community
Hospital, which is expanding to accommodate the change." Washington Post,
January 9, 2001, Pg.B3.
Back to top of page
THE CASE AGAINST CONTRACTING WITH DOCTORS COMMUNITY
HEALTHCARE CORPORATION ("DCHC")
By Councilmember David Catania (At-Large)
The following items are a collection of published accounts regarding
Doctors Community Healthcare Corporation ("DCHC"). At present, the Control Board
is in the process of negotiating an agreement with DCHC to take over operations of the
PBC, including DC General Hospital. Given DCHC's record, I believe that it would be unwise
to entrust one of our most important institutions to this company.
Among the most serious allegations and concerns include:
- DCHC, a for-profit company, is deeply in debt and unprofitable;
- DCHC has a reputation for its inability to complete deals and for 11th hour
demands in negotiations.
Consider the following published accounts:
I. DCHC'S FINANCIAL HISTORY IS EXTREMELY WEAK. MOREOVER, THERE IS NO
EVIDENCE THAT DCHC'S FINANCIAL SITUATION HAS IMPROVED.
"Doctors Community Healthcare Corp. (DCHC) is strapped for cash,
is carrying a huge debt and has posted steep annual losses for the last three years. . . .
. In this years first half, the company reported a $2.6 million loss before taxes on
revenues of $60.5 million. In 1997, it posted a $17 million loss before taxes on revenues
of $109.3 million. The company did not provide after-tax figures for last year. The $17
million loss includes a $5.5 million loss attributed to changes in Medicare and Medicaid
reimbursements and unpaid property taxes in prior years at the companys hospital in
Washington, D.C. In 1996 and 1995, DCHC reported loses of $3.6 million and $3.3 million,
respectively. Restated 1995 financial results following an audit by Ernst &
Young LLP show that DCHC had overstated revenues by $2.3 million. The company
currently has long-term debt of $123 million which excludes debt from the
Reese/Grant transaction. DCHCs total shareholder equity is a negative $22.2 million,
pushing its debt-to-capitalization ratio to a whopping 122% -- a sign of an overleveraged
company with minimal financial flexibility." Crains Chicago Business,
October 12, 1998, Pg. 1 (emphasis added).
As a privately-held corporation, DCHC does not file standard corporate
reports with the Securities and Exchange Commission -- such as 10-Ks. As such, it is
nearly impossible to perform due-diligence into their finances.
II. DCHC & GREATER SOUTHEAST COMMUNITY HOSPITAL: 11th HOUR
NEGOTIATING PRACTICES (1999).
A. DCHC backed out of the original deal only an hour before its announcement.
"Washington, D.C. based Greater Southeast Community Hospital
officials were shocked yesterday when Arizona-based Doctors Community
Healthcare Corp. withdrew its $39 million offer to buy the hospital and its affiliates
only an hour before the deal was to be announced in bankruptcy court the Washington
Post reports. Doctors Community officials said that they were blindsided
by last-minute financial disclosures filed by the near-bankrupt Washington, D.C. hospital,
which included reports that state and federal officials are trying to recover $4.6 million
in overpayments. Doctors Community officials also complained about major
discrepancies in the hospitals inventory of shared and leased medical
equipment, but made clear that they hope to negotiate a new deal with the hospital today.
Greater Southeast, currently facing a $70 million debt, has until tomorrow to secure a
partner or will face a court-ordered liquidation of all of its assets." American
Health Line, November 4, 1999 (emphasis added).
B. With Greater Southeast Community Hospital's back against the wall, DCHC purchased
the hospital for much less than originally agreed upon.
"National Century Financial Enterprises, Dublin, Ohio, provided
$30 million in financing to Doctors Community Healthcare Corp., Scottsdale, Ariz., for its
acquisition of Greater Southeast Community Hospital in Washington. The deal was completed
Dec. 31. The agreement provided for accounts receivable, equipment financing and real
estate bridge commitments for the $22.3 million purchase with more funding available for
closing costs and working capital." Modern Healthcare, February 28, 2000,
Pg. 52.
C. DCHC continues to seek financial advantages from the District.
Paul Tuft, the CEO of Doctors Community Healthcare, proposed a 20 year
property tax exemption at the beginning of 2000, "soon after Doctors Community
purchased Greater Southeast at a bankruptcy sale." The tax exemption could be worth
nearly $1 million a year. Washington Post, January 23, 2001, Pg. B5 (emphasis
added).
D. After the purchase of Greater Southeast, DCHC downsized Hadley.
"The company that owns the two District hospitals east of the
Anacostia River said yesterday that it will consolidate emergency and general medical
services at the larger one and convert the other into a nursing home and long-term acute
care facility. Hadley Memorial Hospital will close its emergency room Feb. 1 and send such
cases to Greater Southeast Community Hospital, which is expanding to accommodate the
change." Washington Post, January 9, 2001, Pg. B3.
III. DCHC & BOSTON REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER: BANKRUPTCY, CLOSURE, AND LAWSUITS
(1997-1999).
A. Boston Regional Medical Center is suing DCHC for backing out of their deal.
"A bankrupt and shuttered Massachusetts hospital late last week
filed suit against a financing company that was supposed to keep it out of trouble and a
for-profit hospital chain that backed out of a deal to buy the facility. Boston Regional
Medical Center, Stoneham, Mass., which closed and filed for bankruptcy last February,
blamed the financing company, Dublin, Ohio-based National Century Financial Enterprises
and its chief executive officer, Lance Poulson, for its demise. The hospital also blamed
Paul Tuft, chairman and CEO of Doctors Community Healthcare Corp., for its trouble. The
lawsuit, filed in U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Boston, seeks unspecified damages for 16 counts
including alleged fraud, misrepresentation, breach of fiduciary duty and civil
conspiracy." . . . "National Century had agreed to back a deal by
Scottsdale, Ariz.-based Doctors Community to buy ailing not-for-profit Boston Regional for
$52 million (July 19, 1999, p.30). National Century also owns a minority stake in Doctors
Community. As the hospital's losses mounted, the deal went sour, and Doctors Community
backed out after 18 months of negotiations. The lawsuit claims that National Century
promised to lend $16 million in working capital to the hospital, provide a line of credit
of up to $4 million and provide long-term financing of about $36 million for the deal. The
suit says the company knew at the time it made these pledges that it did not have the
ability or willingness to follow through." Modern Healthcare, January 24,
2000, Pg. 4 (emphasis added).
According to a complaint filed in U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Boston filed
October 31, 2000: "Doctor Community Healthcare eventually did take over [Boston
Regional Medical Center], in 1997, but financial conditions continued to get worse. The
new DCHC, the lawsuit says, mismanaged money, did not pay taxes or insurance premiums, and
drove the hospital into bankruptcy. It also failed to buy the hospital, as promised, and
did not provide the attorney general with requested information, the lawsuit states."
Worcester Telegram & Gazette, January 16, 2001, Pg. B1 (emphasis added).
B. Despite letter of intent, DCHC never finalized offer to purchase
Boston Regional.
"Doctors Community Healthcare Corp., which had signed a letter of
intent to purchase the facility [Boston Regional] a year ago, was still attempting to
negotiate a lower purchase price as recently as last week, according to one official close
to the bankruptcy proceedings. He said Doctors Community initially offered $50 million but
backed out and substituted an offer of $25 million that the hospital rejected." Boston
Globe, February 21, 1999, Pg.1.
C. Relying on DCHC's more generous initial offer, Boston Regional rejected other
offers to its detriment.
Doctors Community had offered to buy Boston Regional Medical Center,
which sits on a "45-acre parcel overlooking Spot Pond, for $52 million. . . . Doctors
Community, a privately held for-profit health management firm based in Arizona, had
ostensibly outbid Winchester Hospital, which had offered $37 million, and for-profit Tenet
Healthcare Corp. of California, which had bid $39 million. Both wanted to buy the hospital
outright." Boston Globe, October 25, 1999, Pg. A1.
D. Despite the fact that the purchase never occurred, DCHC managed
Boston Regional to DCHC's advantage.
"But between the time Doctors Community and Boston regional signed
an interim agreement in October 1997 and the day the deal fell apart in February (1999) .
. . the hospitals financial condition had worsened. Adding to its woes was a
stipulation in the papers it signed with Doctors Community in which the hospital agreed to
borrow heavily from a Doctors Community-affiliated financing company in order to stay
afloat until the deal closed. The loans of up to $16 million were to be repaid at the
closing or assumed by the newly formed hospital partnership. Doctors Community itself was
borrowing up to $37.5 million from that same financing company, National Century Financial
Enterprises, to pay for its investment in Boston regional. When this financial house
of cards fell in February, Boston Regional found itself without a financial partner but on
the hook for millions borrowed from Doctors Community. Too late to revive the
previous offers, the 195-bed hospital fell into bankruptcy court. . . . Doctors Community
arranged a last-resort mechanism of selling Boston Regionals accounts receivables at
a discount, so that the hospital could get cash in exchange for turning over its right to
insurance reimbursements, and it promised to keep Ricks on as hospital president. Even
before the agreement was finalized, the hospital began paying $50,000 a month in
management fees to Doctors Community last year." Boston Globe, October 25, 1999,
Pg. A1 (emphasis added).
E. DCHC's final offer equaled the assessed value of the valuable land
on which Boston Regional was located.
"The 40-acre parcel [on which Boston Region sits] is appraised by
the town of Stoneham at $25.7 million, according to Stonehams director of assessing,
Elaine Moore." Boston Globe, March 14, 1999, Pg. 1.
"Doctors Community Healthcare Corp., which had signed a letter of
intent to purchase the facility [Boston Regional] a year ago, was still attempting to
negotiate a lower purchase price as recently as last week, according to one official close
to the bankruptcy proceedings. He said Doctors Community initially offered $50 million but
backed out and substituted an offer of $25 million that the hospital rejected." Boston
Globe, February 21, 1999, Pg.1.
IV. DCHC & MICHAEL REESE AND GRANT HOSPITAL: SHAKY FINANCING AND LACK OF
COMMITMENT (1998).
A. DCHC had a difficulty financing the purchase of the two hospitals.
Doctors had difficulty completing the financing for the transaction
with Columbia/HCA for the acquisition of Michael Reese and Grant Hospitals. Chicago
Tribune, November 5, 1998, p. 3N.
"The Arizona-based hospital management company that plans to
acquire ailing Columbia Michael Reese Hospital and Medical Center and Grant Hospital is
itself in need of financial resuscitation, according to company documents provided to
Illinois regulators. Crains Chicago Business, October 12, 1998, Pg. 1.
B. DCHC had to pay a penalty for failing to complete the financing on time.
"Doctors Community Healthcare Corp. of Scottsdale, Ariz., Thursday
obtained a firm commitment from a New York investment bank [Credit Suisse First Boston
Corp] to underwrite its acquisition of Michael Reese Hospital and Medical Center and Grant
Hospital from Columbia/HCA Healthcare Corp. However, it remained unclear whether
Nashville-based Columbia would allow Doctors Community to miss yet another deadline for
closing the transaction. Earlier this month, Doctors Community had to write Columbia
a $2.5 million check to extend the close to Fridays deadline because its financial
commitments werent firm." Chicago Tribune, October 30, 1998, Pg. 3N
(emphasis added).
C. Soon after assuming control of Michael Reese Hospital, DCHC ended
the hospital's relationship with Humana to save money.
"Michael Reese Hospital and Medical Center wont renew its
longtime contract with Humana Inc., saying the health maintenance organization is costing
the South Side hospital too much money. . . . . Humanas customer base is responsible
for 30 percent of the hospitals admissions at a time when the facilitys new
owners are attempting a financial turnaround. But Reese executives said the HMO, which
pays the hospital a fixed rate for medical care services, was paying Reese about half of
what the hospitals expenses were." Chicago Tribune, March 31, 1999, Pg. 1N
(emphasis added).
D. DCHC's Actions at Micheal Reese Hospital negatively impacted neighboring hospital.
"Mercy was unprepared to take on several thousand patients insured
by Humana, Inc. when nearby Michael Reese Hospital and Medical Center decided last March
to drastically curb its relationship with the managed-care plan after a dispute over
rates." Chicago Tribune, April 27, 2000, Pg. 1N.
E. DCHC sought unsuccessfully to merge Michael Reese Hospital with
nearby hospital.
"Michael Reese Hospital and Medical Center has suggested a
possible merger with its closest neighbor and fierce rival on the city's South Side, Mercy
Hospital and Medical Center, sources say. Dennis Patterson, interim president and CEO of
Mercy, confirms that Dr. Enrique Beckmann, Reese's chairman and CEO, approached him last
month to express interest in the two institutions 'working together' on a possible
'relationship'." . . . "Though rebuffed for now, the overture signals Reese's
desire for a merger partner or other merger to help it withstand the financial pressures
it is facing. Both Reese and Mercy are suffering from excess hospital capacity and falling
federal reimbursements." . . . "'There's a population to be served (on the South
Side), but neither has done real well with it in an economically feasible way.', says Don
Hamilton, a partner and health care consultant in Ernst & Young LLP's Chicago office.
'Putting weakness with weakness isn't a way to make strength, but maybe they don't have
alternatives. Maybe they don't need to have two of everything.'" Crain's Chicago
Business, April 10, 2000, Pg. 3.
F. Michael Reese Hospital is located on very valuable land.
"Adding to the drama: Reeses Near South Side real estate is
highly coveted meaning the hospital could be worth more dead than alive.
And its physicians, who were expected to take a big ownership stake in the hospital , have
yet to put in a dime." Crains Chicago Business, February 8, 1999, Pg.
1 (emphasis added).
"Michael Reese Hospital and Medical Center is putting together a
real estate team to evaluate options for its sprawling, and potentially lucrative, South
Side lakefront property." Crain's Chicago Business, March 20, 2000, Pg. 3
(emphasis added).
G. Shortly after DCHC bought Micheal Reese Hospital and Grant Hospital, DCHC quickly
resold Grant Hospital, which was loosing more money under its management.
"The questions of commitment were triggered by how quickly Doctors
Community Healthcare Corp. auctioned off the hospital (Grant). The company bought Grant
from Columbia/HCA Healthcare Corp. just last fall and promised to operate Grant as a
health-care facility. . . . The sale will allow Doctors to focus solely on Michael
Reese, which lost more than $50 million last year. With Grants losses, Doctors may
have had a hard time turning both facilities around. Grants losses went from
between $200,000 and $400,000 a month under Columbia ownership to $600,000 a month once
Doctors Community bought Grant in November." Chicago Tribune, May 21, 1999, Pg.
3N (emphasis added).
"Chicago-based Grant Hospital is on the selling block once again,
a scant three months after Scottsdale, AZ-based Doctors Community Healthcare
Corp, bought it." American Health Line, February 25, 1999.
H. DCHC had difficulty meeting the obligations surrounding the sale of
Grant Hospital.
"But for the struggling Michael Reese Hospital and Medical Center
on Chicagos South Side, a competing hospital holds its fate. Edgewater Medical
Center, a not-for-profit hospital on Chicagos North Side, holds a trump card that
could doom for-profit Michael Reese. Edgewaters ace-in-the-hole is a first mortgage
note secured by prime waterfront real estate- the property atop which 225-bed Micheal
Reese sits. That land is potentially worth triple the value of the paper backing it. If
Michael Reeses for-profit parent, Scottsdale, Ariz.-based Doctors Community
Healthcare Corp., defaulted on the mortgage, 215-bed Edgewater could force the hospital
into foreclosure. . . . Edgeaters potential foreclosure power over Michael Reese
stems from a little-noticed detail in the not-for-profits agreement to buy Grant
Hospital, another Chicago hospital, from Doctors Community this summer. Doctors Community
originally purchased Grant and Michael Reese from Columbia/HCA Healthcare Corp. in
November 1998. As part of the deal, Columbia continued the mortgage on those properties.
But when Doctors Community later decided to sell Grant to Edgewater, it encountered a
snag. . . . To close the Grant deal, Doctors Community persuaded Edgewater to assume a
first mortgage interest on Michael Reese. Edgewater paid $10.9 million to take out the
mortgage. We were told by Doctors Community at the 11th hour that thats
something they would need to get the deal done. Said Edgewaters Zeisel. Modern
Healthcare, September 20, 1999, Pg. 2.
IV. DCHC & NATIONAL CENTURY FINANCIAL ENTERPRISES
("NCFC"): AN UNDENIABLE PARTNERSHIP
A. NCFC is a health care financing company.
"The company [National Century Financial Enterprises], based in
Dublin, Ohio, has made a name for itself in a controversial form of health care financing
that struggling hospitals have increasingly turned to. Under this strategy, hospitals sell
or pledge their expected insurance reimbursements, or accounts receivables, to companies
like National Century, in exchange for cash." The Boston Globe, January 21,
2000, Pg. B4.
"Headquartered in Dublin, OH, National Century Financial
Enterprises, Inc. estimated revenues of approximately $200 million for 1999 and is the
country's largest provider of healthcare accounts receivable financing via its securitized
portfolios. In addition to its Dublin headquarters, NCFE has offices in Scottsdale
AZ." Business Wire, January 24, 2000.
B. NCFC owns over 11% of DCHC.
"Doctors Community was founded in 1991 by Paul Tuft, . . . The
company pursued struggling hospitals, often by forming ownership partnerships with
physicians. . . . National Century Financial Enterprises, a Dublin, Ohio-based financing
company that funds many of Doctors Community's deals, is financing Doctors' purchase of
the hospital [Greater Southeast] as well as providing an upfront loan to Greater Southeast
to tide it over until the purchase is completed. The company, which provides high-interest
loans and lines of credit to struggling healthcare providers that may be shunned by
traditional lenders, has an 11.5% stake in Doctors Community." Modern Healthcare,
November 22, 1999, Pg. 8.
C. DCHC uses NCFC to finance DCHC's efforts.
- Greater Southeast Community Hospital
"National Century Financial Enterprises, Dublin, Ohio, provided $30 million on
financing to Doctors Community Healthcare Corp., Scottsdale, Ariz., for its acquisition of
Greater Southeast Community Hospital in Washington. The deal was completed Dec. 31. The
agreement provided for accounts receivable, equipment financing and real estate bridge
commitments for the $22.3 million purchase with more funding available for closing costs
and working capital." Modern Healthcare, February 28, 2000, Pg. 52.
- Boston Regional Medical Center
"Adding to its [Boston Regional] woes was a stipulation in the papers it signed with
Doctors Community in which the hospital agreed to borrow heavily from a Doctors
Community-affiliated financing company in order to stay afloat until the deal closed. The
loans of up to $16 million were to be repaid at the closing or assumed by the newly formed
hospital partnership. Doctors Community itself was borrowing up to $37.5 million from that
same financing company, National Century Financial Enterprises, to pay for its investment
in Boston Regional. When this financial house of cards fell in February, Boston Regional
found itself without a financial partner but on the hook for millions borrowed from
Doctors Community." Boston Globe, October 25, 1999, Pg. A1.
Michael Reese Hospital and Grant Hospital
"Nov. 12, 1998 Doctors Community Healthcare Corporation (DCHC) and National
Century Financial Enterprises, Inc. (NCFE) today announced the completion of the
acquisition of Michael Reese and Grant Hospitals from Columbia/HCA. The NCFE agreements
provide for accounts receivable and equipment financing commitments totaling $80 million
for the purchase of the hospitals healthcare receivables from third party payers and
equipment financing. The purchase price for both hospitals is $62.5 million plus working
capital." Business Wire, November 12, 1998.
D. NCFC has been investigated for fraudulent activity.
"A major credit-rating service has launched an investigation into
the operations of Dublin-based National Century Financial Enterprises after receiving
three anonymous letters alleging fraudulent activity at the company." The
Columbia Dispatch, May 26, 2000, Pg. 1C.
"Duff & Phelps Credit Rating Co. (DCR) and Fitch IBCA recently
have launched an investigation into the financial records and activities of healthcare
receivables company National Century Financial Enterprises (NCFE) in response to a series
of anonymous letters received separately by both DCR and Asset Sales Report. . . . The
first two letters, addressed to Jeff Orr and dated April 26, 1999, and July 16, 1999,
state that NCFE "operates outside the scope of its indentures and normal business
practices." Further, the writer of the letters alleges that it is estimated
that approximately 50% or more of the $2 billion portfolio is either worthless or
non-existent." Asset Sales Report, May 22, 2000.
V. MORE INFORMATION ON DCHC
DCHC operates the following health care institutions:
- Michael Reese Hospital and Medical Center in Chicago 482-bed;
- Pacifica Hospital of the Valley in Sun Valley, Calif. 242-bed;
- Hadley Memorial Hospital in Washington, D.C. 148-bed;
- Greater Southeast Community Hospital in Washington, D.C. 450-bed;
- Brea Community Hospital (Calif.) 162-bed;
- Pine Grove Hospital, a psychiatric facility in Canoga Park, Calif. 80-bed
Paul R. Tuft, Chairman of the Board and Chief Executive
Officer. Mr. Tuft's was formerly a partner in a law firm in Omaha, Nebraska specializing
in healthcare finance.
Mel Redman, President and Chief Operating Officer. Mr. Redman
spent 25 years at Wal-Mart Stores, Incorporated, where he served as Senior Vice President
of Operations.
Visit their website at www.doctorscommunity.com.
|